Assessment of Heavy Metal Content in Herbal Medicines Used in Pakistan by Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy
Zahida Noreen1*, Iftikhar Hussain
Bukhari2, Atta ul Haq3, Rabia Arshad3
1Department of
Analytical Chemistry, G.C University Faisalabad, Pakistan
2Department of
Chemistry, University of Sargodha, Pakistan
3G.C University
Faisalabad, Pakistan
*Corresponding author: Zahida Noreen,
M.Phil Analytical Chemistry, G.C University Faisalabad, Pakistan. Tel:
+923323232604; Email: zahidanoreen07@gmail.com
Received Date: 26 March, 2018; Accepted
Date: 03 April, 2018; Published Date: 11 April,
2018
Citation: Noreen Z, Bukhari IH, Haq AU, Arshad R (2018) Assessment
of Heavy Metal Content in Herbal Medicines Used in Pakistan by Atomic
Absorption Spectroscopy. Adv Anal Pharm Chem: AAPC-101. DOI: 10.29011/AAPC-101.
100001
Herbal medicines are being regarded with great favor and are appealing for the benefit of the people all over the world. World Health Organization gave importance to the maintenance of standards of herbal medicines specially to test the presence of heavy metals in them. In this research project, branded herbal medicines have been analyzed for the assessment of various heavy metals. The samples were collected from local market of Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan. These medicines were prepared by popular herbal companies of Pakistan and the products are famous among the public. The quantity of the medicine analyzed, were in the form of capsules, pallets, syrups, and pastes (majoons). The medicines were manufactured for analysis by wet digestion method treating them with nitric acid and perchloric acid. The prepared samples were analyzed by atomic absorption spectrometer (AAS) using graphite tube atomizer and equipped with an injection system of MHS-10. The results exhibited that most of the samples crossed the permissible levels of heavy metals such as cadmium (95 %), lead (95), chromium (90 %) and nickel (90 %). However, the quantity of the other metals (Cu, Zn and Fe) were not enough to be harmful for human ingestion in several samples. Few herbal medicines like Ambreena tonic, Hab moqal khas, Ireefal zamani, Zarjam, Majoon sang danamurgh, Allergex and Akseer e jigar demonstrated harmful quantities of almost all the heavy metals analyzed. The results indicated that there is a great requirement to establish a suitable system of maintenance of quality that can elaborate the public for the validation of herbal medicines and make sure the implementation of old laws and standard procedures for public safety.
Keywords: AAS; Heavy metals; Herbal; Majoons; Toxic
1. Introduction
The use of
herbs and plants for medicinal purposes and the study of their use is called
Herbalism or Herbology. Herbs are the basic source of herbal medicines but
there are many herbs that are thought to have adverse effects on human
health. [1]. Many herbal plants have been used for herbal medicines since
ancient times such as Aloe vera,
Marshmallow, Great burdock, Pot marigold, Gota kola, Chinese Yam, Siberian
ginseng and Tea tree etc. Herbal products are used for various ailments as in
Pakistan many branded herbal medicines are used by the people such as Anab is
used for blood purifier, Arq-mako is anti-inflamatory, Dinar used for liver
disorder, Saduri and Toot siah is used to treat cough etc. [2].
There are many
advantages and disadvantages of herbal medicine. Before treating yourself with
herbs or seeking advice from a qualified herbalist or naturopath, consider the
pros and cons of herbal treatments and remedies [3].
1.1. Advantages: There are many advantages of herbal products
such as their cost-effectiveness as compared to allotropic medicines, these
have very little side effects, these have very easy access to a common person,
these can be brought without a prescription etc.
1.2. Disadvantages: Herbal treatment is time consuming and requires
patience, herbs contain various elements which they absorb through roots from
soil, it may be noticeable that body chemistry of patients could not matches
with the ingredients of the herbal products so it may cause allergy [4].
In spite of
the advantages and benefits of the herbal medicines there are many reports that
shows that herbal medicines have been contaminated with heavy metals. As the
metals have low excretion rate when excreted into the kidney which have
damaging effect on humans, even at very low concentrations. Heavy metals have a
tendency to accumulate in the food chain, however, an increase in their uptake
can become toxic. The main intention of current research is to investigate the
content of heavy metals in herbal medicines due to these reasons. Other aim of
this study is the inherent capacity for coming into being the risks of heavy
metals present in herbal medicines based on the World Health Organization (WHO)
standard limits.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Materials
Herbal products were
used in this research to assess the heavy metal concentration for the presence of cadmium, mercury, lead,
arsenic, cuprum and zinc from their solutions prepared in distilled water. The
quantity of herbal medicine analyzed were in the form of capsules, pallets,
syrups, and pastes (majoons) frequently used in Punjab, Pakistan. The medicines
were manufactured for analysis by wet digestion method treating them with
nitric acid and perchloric acid.
2.2. Equipments and Instruments
Atomic
Absorption Spectrometer (JIEBO, AA320N), Electrical
oven (memert Celsius 2005), Hot plate (Lab Tech), Electrical balance (G.C
2102), Grinder (Frith pulverize He.2), De-ionizer, Whatman filter paper, Fume
Hood.
2.3. Chemicals
Nitric acid (HNO3), Perchloric acid (HClO4), Hydrochloric acid
(HCl), Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), Chromic
acid H2CrO4, Cadmium Nitrate Cd(NO3)2, Zinc
granules Zn, Ferrous Ammonium Sulphate (NH4)2.Fe(SO4)2.6H2O,
Manganese chloride MnCl2.2H2O, De-ionized water. All
reagents were analytical grade and contain very low
concentration of trace metals.
2.4. Sampling of Herbal Medicines
The branded
herbal medicines were purchased from Jhang Bazar, a local market in the
district of Punjab, Pakistan. The
samples were mostly syrups and tablets as shown in Table 1. Only
those samples were collected for the study which were famous among the public
and extensively used as over the counter (OTC) products. OTCs are those
medicinal products which can be used without the prescription of physician or
pharmacist. The formulations collected were mostly manufactured by Qurshi,
Hamdard manufacturer and some other well-known herbal industries.
The list of
the twenty sampled herbal medicines is given below in the table.
3. Results
The level of
concentration of heavy metals in the herbal medicines are given in Table
2. All the samples except Itreefal zamani (4.3 ppm) exceeded the
permissible limit for lead (5 ppm). Cr was analyzed in 90 % of the samples to
have crossed the admissible amount (30-35 ppm) whereas Ni concentration
exceeded the permissible limit (1.5 ppm) in 18 samples except Allergex and
Epitize. In the case of cadmium, 19 products (i.e., 95 %) go above the
admissible range (0.5 ppm). Mn, Zn and Fe were discovered within the allowed
range in all the samples.
The highest Pb concentration
was found in Ambreena tonic (31.7 ppm) followed by Hab moqil khas (31.2 ppm),
Deedani (31.00 ppm), Jawahar mohara khas (30.2 ppm) and Akseer e jigar (29.5
ppm). The concentration of Cd was 3.2 - 83.2 ppm with the highest concentration
in Itreefal zamani (83.2 ppm), followed by Zarjam (81 ppm), Bukhareen (9.5
ppm), Ambreena tonic (9.3 ppm), Akseer e jigar (8.2 ppm), Deedani (7.9 ppm) and
Majoon sang dana murgh (6.8 ppm). These values depict that all the samples
crossed the upper limits of the admissible range for Cd.
The highest
amount of Cr was found in Ambreena tonic (141.2 ppm) followed by Majoon sang
dana murgh (140.3 ppm), Deedani (137.2 ppm), Allergex (136.3) and Akseer e
jigar (135.4 ppm). The highest amount of Cu was discovered in Hab moqil khas
(15 ppm) followed by Khameera abresham (14.1 ppm), Majoon sang dana murgh (7.8
ppm), Zarjam (7.3 ppm), Itreefal zamani (6.4 ppm), Jawahar mohara khas (5.9
ppm), and Ahmareen (5.1 ppm). Highest concentration of Iron was found in Hab
moqil khas (601.8 ppm) and lowest concentration was found in Allergex (9.1 ppm).
4. Discussion
The following advocated
daily limits of some of the significant metals will help in the findings of
this research study are given table 3.
4.1. Lead
Lead is one of the most
toxic among toxic heavy metals. It enters the human body in various ways
including inhalation, drinking water, ingestion of food polluted with lead and
absorption by skin. It accumulates in the body has no known useful biological
function [9]. It has adverse effects on various body systems such as the
reproductive, renal, digestive, cardiovascular and immunological
systems [10]. The concentration of lead in the tested products was in
the range of 4.3 - 31.7 ppm. The recommended limit for finished herbal products
is 5 ppm while for crude herbal material it is 10 ppm [11].
Since our
study was conducted on finished herbal products, we consider the 5 ppm as the
applicable limit. Thus, only one product out of the twenty samples assessed had
lead concentration below the recommended limit. It is clear, therefore, that
these products are potentially toxic to man. Incidentally, all these products
are very popular among the people and adult and children chronically use some
of them such as Hab e moqal khas and Majoon suranjan. There is a large body of
data on the adverse effect of lead in herbal formulations human
health [12].
4.2. Cadmium
Cadmium is a toxic metal
of occupational and environmental concern. Cadmium exposure leads to a variety
of adverse effects due to its extremely long biological half-life. The rate of
cadmium transfer from soil to plants is very high and the metal is considered
to have carcinogenic effects on liver, pancreas and stomach [13]. Its
recommended concentration in plant is 3 ppm while for finished plant products,
it is 0.5 ppm [11]. The recommended consumption of cadmium is
70 μg/day [5]. Based on this, 19 products out of 20 exceeded the
permissible limit. The highest Cd consumption are: Itreefal zamani (83.2 ppm),
followed by Zarjam (81 ppm), Bukhareen (9.5 ppm) and Ambreena tonic (9.3 ppm).
4.3. Chromium
Chromium is exists in
two ionic forms, trivalent and hexavalent, the latter being toxic and is correlated
to human carcinogenesis and acute toxicity of aquatic organisms [14]; on
the other hand, its reduced form (trivalent) is an essential element for
animals. The concentration of chromium was in the range of 9.5 - 141.2 ppm.
There is no recommended limit for chromium in herbal finished products. The
recommended limit of chromium is 11 - 25 μg/day for children and 30 -
35 μg/day for adults [6,7]. Highest consumption was observed for
Ambreena tonic (141.2 ppm). Only two products had chromium concentration below
the recommended limit. Such a high concentrations could be toxic due to the
chronic use of some of the tested products.
4.4. Copper
Copper has both
beneficial and toxic effects depending on its level of consumption. Monitoring
of copper limit is essential as it is beneficial in low concentrations but
exhibit various toxic effects above the safety limit. In this study, copper was
found in the products in the concentration range of 2.9 - 15 ppm. The
recommended consumption of copper is 900 and 340 - 400 μg/day for adult
and for child, respectively [6,7]. Thus, all the tested products were
safe with regard to copper content.
4.5. Nickel
Nickel is abundant in
nature. Possible exposure sources of nickel are food, drinking water,
absorption by contact and inhalation in nickel-polluted area [15].
Ingestion of large amounts of nickel affects stomach, liver, kidneys, immune
system and reproduction in rats and mice [15]. The most common toxic
effect is dermatitis while lung cancer has also been reported in some
studies [15]. Nickel was found in a concentration range of 4.5 - 51.3 ppm.
The highest concentration was found in Khameera Abresham (51.3 ppm), followed
by Itreefal zamani (43.4 ppm) and Ambreena tonic (17.9 ppm). The recommended
consumption limit of nickel is 35 μg/day [8]. Thus, almost all
the tested samples exceeded the daily allowed limit for nickel. The contents of
Mn, Zn and Fe in the tested products were within their permissible limits, they
did not exceed the daily consumption limits of these metals.
5. Acknowledgement
First of all, I want to say a special thanks to my honorable
supervisor Prof. Dr. Iftikhar Hussain
Bukhari, Ex-Chairman, Department of Chemistry, Govt. College
University Faisalabad. During my academic activities at campus I found him a
kind and generous person. His untiring guidance, unerring vigor, staunch help,
masterly advices and inspiring stance at all time made it very easy to under
this research and to bring it in present form.
It is my
privilege to record my deepest sense of gratitude to my respected teachers Dr. Atta-ul-Haq, Asstt. Prof. for helping me
to set this paper and Dr. Tanveer
Hussain Bokhari, Asstt. Prof. Department of Chemistry, Govt. College
University Faisalabad, for providing me help in preparing the review.
I want to
express my special thanks to Mr Khalid
Ahmad, owner Shahzad Dawakhana,
Karkhana Bazar, Faisalabad for providing me finished herbal products
on demand.
This research
did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public,
commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
I convey my
special thanks to my sweet friends and research fellow Rabia Arshad who always encouraged and
helped me during the course of my study and research period.
Last but not
least, I express my profound admiration and deepest thanks to my supporting
parents and my siblings Noreen, Imran,
Adnan, Usman and Arsalan, who always stood behind me. It was only due
to their moral support and financial help during my entire academic carrier
that enabled me to complete my work efficiently and proficiently.
May ALLAH give
them His blessings along happy life. Ameen
Figure 1: Heavy metal contents in first ten herbal
medicines (as found on table. 2).
Figure 2: Heavy metal
contents in last ten herbal medicines (as found on table. 2).
No. of obs |
Herbal Medicine |
Batch Number |
Brand name/ Company |
Usage |
Quantity |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 |
Ahmareen |
171214 |
Qarshi |
Liver tonic |
10 mL BD |
|
2 |
Akseer e Jigar |
210116 |
Qarshi |
Liver disorders |
10 mL TDS |
|
3 |
Allergex |
111215 |
Qarshi |
Allergies |
5 mL BDS |
|
4 |
Ambreena tonic |
131015 |
Qarshi |
Digestive, appetite stimulant |
10-15 mL BD |
|
5 |
Bukhareen |
251017 |
Qarshi |
Malaria, fever |
2 tab TDS |
|
6 |
Corezcol |
251215 |
Qarshi |
Whooping cough |
5-10 mL TDS |
|
7 |
Deedani |
241012 |
Qarshi |
Worms killer |
5g OD |
|
8 |
Epitize |
1904 |
Himont |
Eppetite stimulant, |
15ml TDS |
|
9 |
Garlicare |
1 |
Hamdard |
Heart disorders |
1 tab TDS |
|
10 |
Hab Moqil khas |
251114 |
Qarshi |
Acidity, stomach burns |
2 tab TDS |
|
11 |
Habis |
300316 |
Qarshi |
Blood coagulation |
5-10 mL TDS |
|
12 |
Itreefal zamani |
L12-019 |
Hamdard |
Constipation and headache |
5 mL OD |
|
13 |
Jawahar mohara khas |
241114 |
Qarshi |
Heart, brain and nerves disorders |
1 cap BDS |
|
14 |
Khameera Abresham |
8 |
Ajmal |
Protects vital organs |
5 mL BDS |
|
15 |
Majoon sang dana murgh |
311215 |
Qarshi |
Strengthen digestive system |
5 mL TDS |
|
16 |
Majoon suranjan |
290216 |
Qarshi |
Goat, relieve ankle and toe pain |
5-10 mL BDS |
|
17 |
Taryaq e nazla |
261142 |
Qarshi |
Acute catarrh, sore throat, cough |
5-10 mL BDS |
|
18 |
Zanjabeen |
11114 |
Qarshi |
Hyperacidity, nausea, vomiting |
2 cap BDS |
|
19 |
Zarjam |
170415 |
Qarshi |
Sexual debility |
1 cap TDS |
|
20 |
Zubex |
30216 |
Qarshi |
Anti-diabetic |
1 tab TDS |
|
Key: tab = tablet, OD = once daily, BD= twice daily, TDS= thrice daily |
Table 1: Basic information about the herbal medicines.
No. of obs |
Medicine |
Pb |
Cd |
Cr |
Cu |
Ni |
Zn |
Fe |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 |
Ahmareen |
27.2 ± |
6.2 ± |
120.8 ± |
5.1 ± 0.03 |
8.3 ± 0.00 |
7.6 ± 0.01 |
19.3 ± 0.02 |
|
2 |
Akseer e jigar |
29.5± 0.02 |
8.2± 0.01 |
135.4± 0.00 |
3.6 ± 0.01 |
13.2 ± 0.02 |
7.3 ± 0.01 |
17.1 ± 0.02 |
|
3 |
Allergex |
23.4±0.01 |
7.1±0.00 |
136.3±1.30 |
ND |
ND |
7.3±0.01 |
9.1 ± 0.01 |
|
4 |
Ambreena tonic |
31.7± |
9.3±0.01 |
141.2± |
ND |
17.9 ± 0.00 |
16.5± |
20.3 ±0.04 |
|
5 |
Bukhareen |
25.4± |
9.5± 0.05 |
131.3± |
2.9± 0.00 |
7.9 ± 0.02 |
7.4 ± 0.00 |
17.3 ± 0.01 |
|
6 |
Corezcol |
29.2± |
7.3± 0.03 |
121.7± |
5.3±0.01 |
7.4±0.00 |
19.3± |
20.5 ± 0.03 |
|
7 |
Deedani |
31.0±0.04 |
7.9± 0.00 |
137.2±0.05 |
3.0±0.00 |
7.5 ± 0.01 |
9.7 ± 0.00 |
21.3 ±0.04 |
|
8 |
Epitize |
21.9± |
4.3±0.00 |
121.7± |
3.5±0.01 |
ND |
8.1 ± 0.00 |
25.3 ± 0.07 |
|
9 |
Garlicare |
25.6± |
5.1± 0.01 |
130.8± |
ND |
5.4 ± 0.00 |
7.9 ± 0.02 |
11.9 ±0.01 |
|
10 |
Hab Moqal khas |
31.2± |
6.9±0.03 |
81.5 ±0.02 |
15.0± |
7.3 ± 0.00 |
24.5± |
601.8± |
|
11 |
Habis |
21.6± |
3.9± 0.00 |
121.3± |
4.3± |
6.7 ± 0.01 |
ND |
9.6 ± 0.01 |
|
12 |
Itreefal Zamani |
4.3± |
83.2± |
9.5± |
6.4±0.00 |
43.4± |
51.8± |
29.8± 2.02 |
|
13 |
Jawahar mohara khas |
30.2± |
5.1± |
129.8± |
5.9± |
7.6 ± 0.00 |
34.4± |
550.4± |
|
Table 2: Concentration of heavy metals in herbal medicines sampled from Punjab, Pakistan.
Heavy Metal |
Advocated daily limit |
Reference |
|
---|---|---|---|
Cd |
70 μg |
(Obi et al., 2006) [5] |
|
Cu |
340-400 μg (child), |
(IOM, 2001; ATSDR, 2008) [6,7] |
|
Cr |
11-25 μg (child), 30 -35 |
(IOM, 2001; ATSDR, 2008). [6,7] |
|
Fe |
8-10 mg |
(IOM, 2001) [6] |
|
Mn |
8-11 mg |
(IOM, 2001) [6] |
|
Ni |
35 μg |
(Forstner & Wittmann, 1981) [8] |
|
Pb |
20-514 μg |
(Obi et al., 2006) [5] |
|
Zn |
3-8 mg |
(IOM, 2001) [6] |
|
Table 3: Recommended daily limits for some metals.