Efficacy, Evidence and Elegance of JRK’s AF Antifungal Cream
Priya R,
Amruthavalli GV*, Aruna V, Gayathri R
Dr. JRK’s Research and Pharmaceuticals Pvt Ltd., Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
*Correspondingauthor: Amruthavalli GV, Dr. JRK’s Research and Pharmaceuticals Pvt., Ltd., Kundrathur,Chennai-600 069, Tamil Nadu, India. Tel: +919940327847; Email: amruthavalli_gv@jrksiddha.com; amrutha.valli4@gmail.com
Citation: Priya R, Amruthavalli GV, Aruna V, Gayathri R (2017) Efficacy, Evidence and Elegance of JRK’s AF Antifungal Cream. Clin Exp Dermatol Ther: CEDT-132.
The anti-fungal
efficacy of JRK’s AF antifungal cream was evaluated both by in vitro and by
clinical trial. The in vitro studies have shown
that JRK’s AF antifungal cream is extremely effective against wide range of
fungal pathogens viz., dermatophytes, species of Candida and Pityrosporum ovale. The clinical
findings also shown that in two weeks usage of JRK’s AF cream has completely
relieved all the patients from severe fungal infections such as Tinea cruris,
Tinea corporis, Candidiasis and Pityriosis vercicolor. The above findings
clearly establish the validity, efficacy and the scientific sanctity of Siddha
system of medicine and the two-important herbal antifungal drugs used in the cream
such as Cassia alataand Azadirachta indica.
1. Introduction
Cutaneous mycosis is
an emerging problem and is largely considered as major public health problem [1,2].
The cutaneous mycosis always limits to the superficial layer of the skin by
limiting itself to stratum corneum, nail and hair [2,3]. Except Pityriasis
versicolor, Candidiasis and dermatophytosis are symptomatic and cause
severe itching due to their metabolites [4]. Treating cutaneous fungal
infections is although easy but the patients with underlying conditions often
show susceptibility to chronic infections which seldom respond to treatment.
Variety of antifungal drugs are available for the treatment of cutaneous mycosis
but the emerging anti-fungal drug resistance pose serious challenge to medical
fraternity [5]. Therefore, safe, effective and non-specific broad spectrum
anti-fungal agents are essential.
Siddha system
of medicine is gifted to mankind by people with supernal wisdom and supreme
spiritual attainment. Siddha system of medicine has several references of
anti-fungal drugs and among them are the preparations with Cassia alataand
neem [6-8]. Neem is considered to be a magical herb where its root to the terminal
parts is medicinal and the medicinal value of neem cannot be described so
easily [9].
JRK’s AF antifungal
cream is a proprietary siddha drug formulated with two credible anti-fungal
siddha herbs such as Cassia alataand Azadirachta indica. Our
earlier study using corneosurfametry has clearly shown that AF cream blocks the
fungal adhesion. Blocking the fungal adhesion is quite novel and it can treat
the cutaneous mycosis and simultaneously can avoid the possible drug resistance
by the organism [10]. The present study is aimed at evaluating the antifungal
activity of AF cream against different species of fungal pathogens viz., Candida
albicans,Pityrosporum ovale and Trichophyton mentagrophytes.
We have employed three different techniques such as MIC, determination of
static effect and contact time Vs rate of kill.
After establishing
the antifungal effect of AF cream at laboratory level we have also subjected
the siddha drug for rigorous clinical trial on patients with various cutaneous
fungal infections over a period of 4 weeks. The findings are presented in the
paper.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Determination of MIC
Saboraud’s dextrose
agar medium was used for MIC evaluation. Tween supplementation was used for
studying P.ovale. P.ovalesuspension adjusted to achieve
41 colonies/ml was used as inoculum. In case of C.albicans, the
culture suspension was adjusted to 109 colonies/ml. In the case of T.mentagrophytesthe
spore suspension was prepared in such a way to achieve confluent colony
covering the entire petri dish.
The AF cream was
incorporated with the medium separately at 1mg/ml, 0.5 mg/ml and 0.1mg/ml
concentration and the above adjusted cultures were inoculated and the number of
colony forming units were measured at either on day 2 and day 5 whichever is
applicable.
2.2. Determination of Static Effect of AF Cream
5 mm well was made
in saboraud’s dextrose agar medium containing JRK’s AF antifungal cream at
1mg/ml concentration. 5 mm plug prepared out of the respective fungi that were
grown separately were placed in the well and the plates were allowed to
incubate at 24ºC for 2-5 days whichever is applicable.
The growth extension
of the respective fungi that grown in the media with and without AF cream were
compared and the static effect was arrived.
2.3. Contact Time Vs Rate of Kill
Into the spore/cell
suspension of the 3 fungi 1mg/ml concentration of AF cream or C+ or A+ complex
separately and incubated for 10 min. After 10 minutes, the spore suspension was
plated on to plain Saboraud’s dextrose agar medium and incubated for 2 -5 days
whichever is applicable and the number of colonies grown were counted and
compared with control to arrive the percentage kill Vs time.
2.4. Clinical Trials on JRK’s AF Antifungal Cream
Clinical trial was
done at quest life sciences as per complete bio ethical norms applicable for
clinical trials.
2.4.1. Type of Study:Prospective interventional clinical end
point study (Pilot study).
· Study Design: A randomised open
label single arm clinical study.
· Study Population: Patients suffering
from Cutaneous Candidiasis or Dermatophytosis (Tinea/ Ring worm) or Pityriasis
versicolor (Chromic/ Achromic).
· Sample Size: 20 patients
diagnosed with either of the skin conditions like Cutaneous Candidiasis or
Dermatophytosis (Tinea/ Ring worm) or Pityriasis Versicolor (Chromic/
Achromic)
2.4.2. Selection Criteria
· Inclusion
Criteria: The following criteria’s will be considered for subject
enrollment in the study. Subjects in the age group between 18 to 75 years,
inclusive of both male and female subjects. Availability of subject for the
entire study period and willing to adhere to protocol requirements as evidenced
by the written ICF duly signed by the volunteer. Subject who have no evidence
of life-threatening disease during screening, medical history and whose
physical examination is performed within 28 days prior to commencement of the
study. Subjects suffering from either Cutaneous Candidiasis or Dermatophytosis
(Tinea/ Ring worm) or Pityriasis Versicolor (Chromic/ Achromic). Atopic
patients, dry skin and diabetes mellitus – definitely patients with either of
the above problem and willing not to use any other anti-fungal drugs other than
the investigational product during the study period. Two week wash out period
may be required prior to the inclusion of patients to the study. Volunteers,
who are willing to avoid sun bathing, swimming, prolonged sun exposure or artificial
ultra-violet rays during the course of the study. Patients with localized
epidermal dermatophytosis confirmed by presence of fungal hyphae in KOH
(potassium hydroxide) preparation of skin scrapings from over the lesion at
baseline visit.
· Exclusion
Criteria: Volunteers with allergies to cosmetics, moisturizers, and
whitening/bleaching agents. Volunteer who has sunburned, chapped, or irritated
skin or open wounds on test sites. Volunteer who are not willing to discontinue
any other personal care products containing whitening/bleaching properties
during study. History of skin cancer or treatment for any type of cancer within
the last 2 years. Volunteer who are with underlying immunosuppression.
Volunteer who applied any other topical agent over the lesions prior to
baseline visit.
· Restrictions: All
the patients will be advised to restrict the use of antibiotics other than
specified in the department protocol of the hospital. Patients will be
instructed not to bathe, shower, wash or swim for at least 4 hours after the
application of the study medication.
2.4.3. Intervention
The patients who
fulfil the inclusion and exclusion criteria will be selected for the study. The
start of therapy is considered as Visit 1 (Day 1). This is followed by Visit 2
(Day 7±1) and Visit 3 (Day 14 ±2).
Visit 1 (Day 1): Those patients who satisfy the inclusion and exclusion
criteria will be recruited for the study. Evaluation of the response will be
done by an Investigator/study team member (Dermatologist). The patient will be
assessed as mentioned below for efficacy parameters and will be documented. Any
concomitant medications taken by patients will be recorded. Test product will
be applied topically on the affected area twice daily in morning and evening at
the interval of every 12 hours (for example, 08.00 AM and 08.00 PM). Each
patient will receive study drug until their next visit. They will also be
instructed to come to the next visit as per schedule and report to the doctor
for any unscheduled visit in case of adverse events. Patients will also be
advised to update their patient compliance card/patient diary on daily basis
until study completion. Patients will be told to return the empty medication
tubes during the next visit.
Visit 2 (Day 7±1): Patients will be asked for any adverse events. Patients
will be observed for any local or systemic adverse events due to study drug.
All adverse events will be recorded in the CRF. All the patients will be
assessed as mentioned below for efficacy parameters by the investigator and
will be documented in the respective CRF. Number of days since the previous
visit during which the patient missed the drug due to unacceptable adverse
events or missed doses will be asked for and recorded. Medications will be dispensed
as mentioned above and the patients will be told to return the empty medication
tubes on the next visit. They will also be instructed to come to the next visit
as per the schedule and report to the doctor for any unscheduled visit in case
of adverse events.
Visit 3 (Day 14): Patients will be asked for any adverse events.
Patients will be observed for any local or systemic adverse events due to study
drug. All adverse events will be recorded in the CRF. All the patients will be
assessed as mentioned below for efficacy parameters by the investigator and
will be documented in the respective CRF. Number of days since the previous
visit during which the patient missed the drug due to unacceptable adverse
events or missed doses will be asked for and recorded. Empty medication tubes
as well as remaining medication tubes will be collected for
accountability.
Efficacy Assessment:
An assessment will be made based on the presence or absence of fungal elements
in KOH preparation and mycological cure. Additionally, during each visit,
subject will be enquired regarding the symptomatic change from the initial
stage and reduction in itching and scaling.
Visit 4 (Day 21): Patients will be asked for any adverse events. Patients
will be observed for any local or systemic adverse events due to study drug.
All adverse events will be recorded in the CRF. All the patients will be
assessed as mentioned below for efficacy parameters by the investigator and
will be documented in the respective CRF. Number of days since the previous
visit during which the patient missed the drug due to unacceptable adverse
events or missed doses will be asked for and recorded. Empty medication tubes
as well as remaining medication tubes will be collected for accountability.
Post Treatment Enquiry: Patients were contacted telephonically on day 28 to check the
recurrence of disease if any or its symptoms like itching or scaling. All the
patients reported of no recurrence of the disease as they are completely cured
of by JRK’s AF cream.
3. Results
3.1. Determination of MIC
At 0.1 mg/ml
concentration of AF cream, the percentage reduction of P.ovalewas
26.8, Candida at 8.2 and T.mentagraphytes10%. At 0.5 mg/ml
concentration, AF cream exhibited the activity in reducing the number of colony
forming units to 21.9 %, 74.31% and 60% respectively for P.ovale,C.albicansand T.mentagraphytes.
At 1 mg/ml AF cream exhibited total inhibition of all the organisms.
AF cream at 10 min
contact had killed about 90% of the cells of all the organisms whereas C + or
A+ complex did not show such effect individually.
3.2. Clinical Trial Findings of JRK’s AF Anti-Fungal Cream
4. Discussion
The findings have
shown that JRK’s Af anti-fungal cream is extremely effective for the treatment
of various cutaneous fungal diseases. Present laboratory studies have
undoubtedly established that JRK’s Af anti-fungal cream possesses strong
anti-fungal activity against various species of fungi such as P.ovale, C.albicansand T.mentagrophytes.The
laboratory findings clearly show that AF cream possesses broad spectrum
antifungal activity.
The combination of
CA+ complex is indeed superior in its efficacy over either of the individual
constituents crediting the strong synergistic effect for the above. AF cream
not only blocks the fungal adhesion but also kill the fungi. Further the extent
of kill is quite quick and rapid. The broad spectrum anti-fungal effect of JRK’s
Af anti-fungal cream indeed makes it superior in the context of the AF cream
having fungal adhesion blockage.
The clinical trial
finding was in full agreement with laboratory findings. In two weeks,
remarkable reduction in itching, scaling and other signs and symptoms of fungal
infections were observed. The Tinea corporisand T. crurishas responded very
well in patients who were diabetic and some of the patients were in the
menopause stage.
These findings
superimpose that anti-fungal efficacy of JRK’s Af anti-fungal cream and its
therapeutic efficacy even in patients with strong predisposition for fungal
diseases. To the best of our understanding JRK’s Af anti-fungal cream is the
only product that has the following benefits
1. Blocks
the fungal adhesion.
2. Possess
antifungal activity.
3. Restrict
the fungal recolonization.
4. Kill
the fungi in 10 min contact time.
All the above
benefits are extremely inevitable for the treatment of active lesions as well
as chronic lesions of cutaneous mycosis irrespective of the underlying
conditions as AF cream is effective in both blocking the fungal adhesion as
well as evicting the fungi. These findings testify the fundamental principle of
siddha system of healing where the siddha preparations correct the Tridosha
(eliminate the root cause) as well as etiological agent. Similarly, the JRK’s
Af anti-fungal cream block the adhesion which is parallel to correcting the
tridosha and eliminate the causative agent which metaphorically equivalent to
addressing the etiology.
Figure 1: Determination of static effect of AF cream.
Graph 1: Complete reduction in 2 weeks with JRK's AF anti-fungal cream.1àMild reduction; 2à Moderate reduction; 3àComplete reduction;0à No recurrence.
|
% Reduction of the organisms |
Control (No. of colonies CFU/ml) |
||
Organisms |
||||
0.1mg/ml |
0.5mg/ml |
1 mg/ml |
||
P.ovale |
26.8 |
21.9 |
100 |
41 |
C.albicans |
8.2 |
74.31 |
100 |
109 |
T.mentagrophytes |
10 |
60 |
100 |
Abundant |
Table 1: Growth of all the organisms were inhibited totally by AF cream when compared to control.
Organism
|
Extent of growth |
|
Test |
Control |
|
P.ovale |
No growth |
Growth |
C.albicans |
No growth |
Growth |
T.mentagrophytes |
No growth |
Growth |
Table 2: Determination of static effect of AF cream.
Organism
|
Percentage reduction of organisms |
|||
Control |
AF cream |
C+ |
A+ |
|
P.ovale |
54 |
100 |
94.4 |
98.1 |
C.albicans |
313 |
99.05 |
95.5 |
75.3 |
T.mentagrophytes |
Abundant (100 app) |
98 |
57 |
77 |
Table 3: Contact time Vs rate of kill within 10 min.
Diagnosis |
No. of patients |
Reduction in signs and symptoms vis-à-vis duration of treatment/No. of patients |
|||||||
Week 1 |
Week 2 |
Week 3 |
Week 4(treatment withdrawn) |
||||||
Itching |
Scaling |
Itching |
Scaling |
Itching |
Scaling |
Itching |
Scaling |
||
Tinea corporis |
6 |
++/4 |
++/5 |
+++/5 |
+++/5 |
+++/6 |
+++/6 |
No recurrence |
|
Tinea cruris |
6 |
++/5 |
++/4 |
+++/5 |
+++/6 |
+++/6 |
+++/6 |
No recurrence |
|
Pitriasis versicolor |
4 |
+++/4 |
+/1 |
+++/4 |
+++/3 |
+++/4 |
+++/4 |
No recurrence |
|
Candiasis |
4 |
+/1 |
++/4 |
+++/4 |
+++/4 |
+++/4 |
+++/4 |
No recurrence
|
|
+ àMild reduction ++ à Moderate reduction +++ à Complete reduction |
Table 4: Clinical Trial Findings.
- Calado NB, deSousa Jr FC, Diniz MG, Fernandes AC, Cardoso FJ, et al. (2011) A 7-year survey of superficial and cutaneous mycoses in a public hospital in Natal, Northeast Brazil. Brazilian Journal of Microbiology 42: 1296-1299.
- Almeida LM, Souza EA, Bianchin DB, Svidzinski TI, et al.(2009) In vitro response of cutaneous mycosis fungal agents to the most widely used systemic antifungals in dermatology. An Bras Dermatol 84: 249-255.
- Dias MFRG, Quaresma-Santos MVP, Bernardes-Filho F, Amorim AGF, Schechtman RC, et al. (2013) Update on therapy for superficial mycoses: review article part I. An Bras Dermatol 88:764-774.
- Badiee P, HashemizadehZ (2014) Opportunistic invasive fungal infections: diagnosis & clinical management. Indian Journal of Medical Research 39: 195-204.
- Keng-EE Thai (2014) Therapies for common cutaneous fungal infections. Medicine Today 15: 35-47.
- Timothy SY, Wazis CH, Adati RG and Maspalma ID (2012) Antifungal Activity of Aqueous and Ethanolic Leaf Extracts of Cassia alata Linn. Journal of Applied Pharmaceutical Science 02: 182-185.
- Sher A (2009) Antimicrobial activity of natural products from medicinal plants. Gomal Journal of Medical Sciences 7: 72-78.
- JR Krishnamoorthy, S Ranganathan, SG Shankar, MS Ranjith (2006) Dano: A herbal solution for dandruff. African Journal of Biotechnology 5: 960-962.
- Kausik Biswas, Ishita Chattopadhyay, Ranajit K Banerjee, Uday Bandyopadhyay. Biological activities and medicinal properties of neem (Azadirachta indica). Current Science 82: 1336-1345.
- Aruna V, Amruthavalli GV and Gayathri Rajagopal (2016) Effect of AF-Anti Fungal Cream on Stratum Corneum and its Importance in Treating Cutaneous Mycoses. Journal of Developing Drugs 5: 1-3.