Perforating Wounds of the Ocular Globe and its Appendices: Epidemiological, Clinical and Therapeutic Aspects at Lubumbashi University Clinics
Maloba NV1, Mukengeshayi NA2,
Borasisi CG1
1Ophthalmologist and Professor at the Faculty of Medicine at Unilu,
Democratic Republic of the Congo
2Epidemiologist at the Janson Sendwe Provincial Referral Hospital
and Associate Professor at the University of Lubumbashi.
3Ophthalmologist at the Lubumbashi University Clinic, Professor at
the University of Lubumbashi
*Corresponding author: Viviane Ngoie Maloba, Ophthalmologist and Professor at the Faculty of Medicine at Unilu, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Tel: +243 998248966; Email: vivianemaloba@yahoo.fr
Received Date: 20 May, 2019; Accepted
Date: 28 May, 2019; Published
Date: 05 June, 2019
Citation: Maloba VN, Mukengeshayi NA, Borasisi CG (2019) Perforating Wounds of the Ocular Globe and its Appendices:
Epidemiological, Clinical and Therapeutic Aspects at Lubumbashi University
Clinics. Ophthalmol Res Rep 4: 132. DOI: 10.29011/ORRT-132.100032
Aim: To determine the epidemiological, clinical and therapeutic
characteristics of perforating wounds of the eyeball.
Method: This is a retrospective descriptive documentary study conducted in
the ophthalmology department of the Lubumbashi university clinics, from January
2010 to December 2013. We recorded 59 patient files with perforating wounds of
the eyeball with or without reaching the annexes. We studied sociodemographic
and clinical variables.
Results: The frequency of perforating wounds of the eyeball was 0.5% on
11458 compiled records. Male patients accounted for 68.4%. The average age of
patients was 16.9 with extremes ranging from 7 months to 59 years; patients
aged between 19 and 40 years were the majority, i.e., 33.9%. The injury was
52.5% for the right eye and 47.5% for the left eye. Metallic agents were
responsible for eye trauma in 33.9% of domestic accidents accounted for 26.7%
of cases. The corneal wound was noted in 47.5% of cases, the corneal foreign
body involved 5% of patients. Absolute blindness was noted in 18.8% of
patients, while 52.5% of patients had almost complete blindness. The functional
results depended on the time between the occurrence of the trauma and the
effectiveness of the management.
Conclusion: The perforating wounds of the eyeball constitute a health problem
that requires a vast public awareness campaign and urgent management of
lesions.
Keywords: Appendix: Eye ball
wound; Frequency
1. Introduction
The World Health Organization estimates that more than 55 million
ocular trauma occur each year with total temporary disability exceeding 24
hours. It shows that of these 20,000 are open eye trauma and 1.6 million
patients with bilateral blindness; 2.3 million with bilateral vision loss and
more than 19 million patients with blindness or unilateral posttraumatic vision
loss [1,2]. In Africa, the prevalence of perforating wounds of the eyeball
among patients received in ophthalmic service remains important and varies from
one country to another. In 1992, it was 30% in Senegal [3]. In the same year,
prevalence rates of 12.4% and 48% were reported respectively in Tunisia and
Morocco [4,5].
In the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), the prevalence of eye
pleasure remains unknown while the perforating wounds of the globe are also
responsible for blindness and low vision in our environment. The main objective
of this study was to determine the epidemiological and clinical characteristics
of the patients received at the ophthalmology department of the University
Clinics of Lubumbashi.
2. Method
This descriptive cross-sectional study was carried out at
Lubumbashi University Clinics. We analyzed the medical records of 11458
patients consulted at ophthalmology departments of University Clinics of
Lubumbashi between January 2010 and December 2013. The studied variables were:
sex, age, profession, plains, laterality, nature traumatic agent, the location
of the lesion, the consultation time, the circumstances of the wound, the
presence or absence of intraocular foreign body, patient management and
post-traumatic complications. We used the usual statistics (percent, mean,
standard deviation) to profile our study population.
3. Results
Demographic profile of patients (Table 1)
Of the 11458 patients consulted during the study period, 59 (0.5%)
had perforating wounds. Wounds were common in patients aged 19-40 years
(33.9%). Children under 5 and 6-12 accounted for 32.2% and 23.7% respectively
of perforating wounds. The sex ratio of the patients was 2.28 men for a woman.
Students and students accounted for more than half of patients (53.4%).
3.1. Clinical profile
This Table 2 shows that all the patients involved in the study had
unilateral involvement with 52.5% for the right eye and 47.5% for the left eye,
respectively. Metal agents accounted for 33.9% of eye trauma while wood, glass
and stone accounted for 13.6%, 15.3% and 13.6%, respectively. Road traffic
accidents, the blow on the eye together accounted for 22.0% of the causes of
wounds. Regarding the circumstances of occurrence, more than a quarter (26.7%)
of perforating wounds were due to domestic accidents, i.e., 26.7% of cases and
games played by children, i.e., 21.6% of cases. Occupational accidents
accounted for 15.1% of all perforating palms, and road accidents accounted for
11.7% of eye trauma.
In terms of seat, the wounds had a corneal predominance (47.5% of
cases), they were corneo-scleral in 27.1% cases. Localized eyelid wounds
accounted for 16.9% of cases, while associated eyeball and appendix involvement
was found in 8.5% of cases. More than one-third, 67.8% of patients had
consulted after 24 hours; 20.3% of patients had done so within 24 hours and
11.9% within 6 hours. The majority of patients, 95.0%, did not have the
intraocular foreign body associated with their wounds.
This Table 3 shows that ocular trauma was responsible for absolute
blindness in 18.8% of patients, while 52.5% of patients had almost complete
blindness, 8.3% of patients had profound visual impairment 6.7% of patients had
severe visual impairment, 3.3% of patients had moderate visual impairment.
3.2. Treatment, evolution and complications
All patients were medically and surgically treated. The medical
treatment was local and general consisting of antibiotics, steroidal or
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, anti-tetanus serum. Surgical management
consisted of a repair of wounds under anesthesia associated or not with the
extraction of foreigners. Complications were made of: cataract (23.3% of
cases), hernia of the iris (16.7% of cases), atrophy of the eyeball (5% of
cases), endophthalmitis (3%) 3% of cases) and hyphema (1.7% of cases) (Figure
1).
4. Discussion
Among the 59 medical files of post-traumatic perforating wounds
patients, our study shows a clear male predominance in 68.4% of cases, i.e., a
sex ratio of 2.28 men for a woman. Our results are consistent with those of
African and Western authors: Meda in Burkina Faso [6], Lam [3] in Senegal and
Lala-Gitteau [7] in France, which report a perforation rate of 70.73%; 69.4%;
93% of cases. Male dominance raises the fear of human exposure to various
activities that may be domestic, industrial, sports and also by the turbulence
of male subjects. The ocular traumatology literature indicates that the man is
more often affected than the woman and it is in the context much more of an
accident of work [8].
In our series the average age of patients with trauma with
perforating eyeball was 16.9 years with extremes ranging from 7 months to 59
years. But patients whose age was between 19 and 40 years were more numerous
with a frequency of 33.9% of cases. The result found in our study is consistent
with those of African and Western authors. Valle [9] in France, studying
oculopelteal trauma had found a high frequency for the age group between 30 and
40 years; Sebilleau [10] found the average age range of 35.4 years in a study
that was conducted in France. This high frequency in the age group of 19 to 40
years for our study is explained by the fact that it is a slice of autonomy and
responsibility, during which the recovery to activities is maximum. Children
aged 7 months to 12 years accounted for a significant portion (55.3%) in our
series. We found that the frequency of perforating wounds increased gradually
with age, which could be explained by the turbulence of the young boys during
the different games. The literature indicates that most wounds are in young
adult males, the average age of onset being 36 years in men [2].
We found a frequency of 0.5% or 59 cases of perforating wounds of
the eyeball and its appendices out of a total of 99.5% or 11458 patients
consulted during the period of the study. Sekkat [4] found in a study conducted
in Morocco a frequency of 12.41%. Lam [3] in turn report a frequency of 22% in
a study conducted in Senegal. WHO estimates that of the more than 55 million
eye injuries that occur each year, 20 miles are open-globe or wound-related
[2].
The attack was unilateral with predominance of the right eye
(52.5%) compared to the left eye (47.5%) without bilateral involvement in our
series. Our results corroborate with Senegal's Seck [11] results and contradict
Kaimbo's results in Kinshasa [12], which report a frequency predominated by the
left eye. Although we have noted a predominance of the right eye, we share the
idea of Sekkat [4] in France, for whom if a difference appears in the frequency
of the trauma between the right eye and the left eye, it does not may be due to
the chance of the trajectory of the projectile.
In our series it appears that the metallic causal agent was
frequent in 33.9% of cases. The occurrence of perforating wounds was dominated
by domestic accidents in 26.7% of cases. This is consistent with the study of
Gaboune [5] in Marrakech. Games played by children accounted for 21.6% of
eyeball wounds. In Senegal, Lam [3] found 58% of cases at gambling and 13.6%
related to domestic accidents.
The cornea was the anatomical structure of the eye most concerned
with perforating wounds with a frequency of 47.5% of cases in our series. SIDI
reports a frequency of 79.4% [13] in a study conducted in Tunisia. Wounds
associating the eyeball with the appendages were found in 8.5% of cases.
Several authors agree that the external topographic location of the cornea
would explain its great exposure to ocular wounds.
In our series, patients consulted in 67.8% of cases 24 hours after
the occurrence of the trauma, 20.3% had consulted between 7-24 hours, 11.9% of
cases had consulted in the first 6 hours that followed the trauma. By cons Beby
in France, found that 79.9% of trauma especially in children, were seen in
consultation the same day [14]. The delay in consultation was also noted by
Sekkat [4] in 75.85% of cases who had consulted after 48 hours in Morocco, Meda
in Burkina Faso [6] had found in 27.4%; Yaya in Central Africa had found in
91,9% after 48 hours [15]. Lam [3], however, noted in their study that 10% of
subjects in their series had consulted within the first 6 hours in Senegal. We
remain in the neighborhoods of their results with 11.9% of cases of consultation
in the 6 hours’ post - traumatic in our series. This high rate of delayed
consultation in our community, as elsewhere in Africa, could be explained by
the remoteness of specialized health structures from the target population, by
the behavior of patients who prefer to start with self-medication, for others
who are starting by traditional treatment or patients who start with
non-specialized structures. Some patients underestimate the initial lesion by
the fact that sometimes the lesion is painless and probably the cost of care.
Our study showed that ocular trauma was responsible for unilateral
blindness in 71.3% of cases and 18.3% of cases of visual impairment. Lam [3] in
Senegal reports a loss of visual function in 95%, Meda reported to Burkina Faso
admission at a visual acuity reduced to the light perception of the eye reached
in 60.87% [6]. The visual prognosis depends on the importance of the shock
received by the eye, the extent of the wound and the ocular structures affected
by the trauma.
The intraocular foreign body was present in 5% of the cases, all
with corneal localization. The existence of intraocular foreign bodies in
ocular trauma with perforating wounds occurred in case of domestic accidents.
All our patients had received medical and surgical treatment (repair of the
wound associated or not with the extraction of the foreign body). The medical
treatment consisted of antibiotic therapy associated with anti-inflammatory
drugs and anti-tetanus serum.
Complications of perforating wounds of the globe were diverse:
cataract in 23.3% of cases, hernia of the iris 16.7% of cases, atrophy of the
eyeball in 5%, endophthalmia in 3.3%, hyphema in 3.7%. The literature reports
that eye trauma to the eyeball is one of the causes of blindness and low vision
in the world [2].
5. Conclusion
Eye trauma is a relatively common reason for consultation in our
community. However, the visual prognosis is poor given the shortage of
ophthalmic centers and ophthalmologists in rural areas, negligence on the part
of parents and / or patients, the limited financial resources of the Congolese
population on the one hand. On the other hand, the corneal involvement often
led to the appearance of leucoma and astigmatism thus contributing to reduce
visual acuity.
6. Conflict of Interest
None.
Figure
1: Complications were made of: cataract (23.3% of cases),
hernia of the iris (16.7% of cases), atrophy of the eyeball (5% of cases),
endophthalmitis (3%) 3% of cases) and hyphema (1.7% of cases).
Age/Year |
Sex |
Total |
Percentage |
|
Male |
Female |
|||
0-2 |
3 |
5 |
8 |
13.6 |
3-5 |
7 |
4 |
11 |
18.6 |
6-12 |
8 |
6 |
14 |
23.7 |
13-18 |
3 |
0 |
3 |
5.1 |
19-40 |
17 |
3 |
20 |
33.9 |
>40 |
3 |
0 |
3 |
5.1 |
Total |
41 |
18 |
59 |
100.0 |
Table 1: Distribution of
patients by age and sex.
Variables |
% (n=59) |
Laterality |
|
Right eye |
52.5 |
Left eye |
47.5 |
Agent causal |
|
Wood |
13.6 |
Metal |
33.9 |
Pierre |
15.3 |
Plastic object |
1.7 |
Glass object |
13.6 |
Other |
22.0 |
Circumstances of occurrence |
|
Aggression |
10.0 |
Domestic accident |
26.7 |
Road accident |
11.7 |
Work accident |
15.1 |
Thu |
21.6 |
Other |
15.0 |
Siege the wound |
|
Corneal |
47.5 |
Corneo-scleral |
27.1 |
Eyelid |
16.9 |
Eye ball + Appendix |
8.5 |
Consultation time |
|
≤ 6h |
11.9 |
7h-24h |
20.3 |
>24h |
67.8 |
Intraocular foreign body |
|
Corneal |
5.0 |
Other |
95.0 |
Visual acuity |
Effective |
Percentage |
NIHIL |
3 |
18.8 |
PL |
31 |
52.5 |
≤ CD 1m |
5 |
8.3 |
CD 1m- ≤ 3m |
4 |
6.7 |
CD 3m-1/10 |
2 |
3.3 |
≥ 3/10 |
14 |
23.3 |
Total |
59 |
100.0 |
- Kaya G, Ngouoni G, Ondzotto G, Botaka E,
Kimbouri AF, et al. (2008) Trauma of the eye and its annexes to the hospital
and university of Brazzaville. Medicine of Black Africa 10: 505-513.
- Adrans D, Hophin (2002) Ophthalmology for
assistance and superior technique in ophthalmology. Masson.
- Lam A, Ndiaye MR (1992). Eye trauma in
Senegal: epidemiological and statistical review of 1872 cases. Medicine of
Black Africa 39: 810-815.
- Sekkat A, Berbich A (1980) Eye trauma:
Report of the Afro-Asian Congress of Ophthalmology, Session III and IV, Acta
Tunis 122.
- Gaboune L, Benfdil N, Sayouti A, Khoumiri
L, Benhaddou R (2007) Eye trauma: clinical and epidemiological aspects at the
University Hospital of Marrakech. French Journal of Ophthalmology 2007; 275.
- Meda N, Gbe K, Sankara P, Ahnoux-Zabsonre
A, Boni S, et al. (2008) Epidemiological, clinical and therapeutic aspects of
serious eye trauma in children at the Yalgado Ouedraogo. University Hospital
Center in Ouagadougou. SOAO 2: 14-19.
- Lala GE (2006) Intraocular foreign body: descriptive study and demonstration of the prognostic factors of 52 cases. French Journal of Ophthalmology 29: 502-508.
- Poujol L, Hallay
J (2000) Ocular Traumatology: Issues of Ocular Pathology. 3rd
Edition 3: 2-6.
- Valle D (2007)
Oculopalpebral trauma: epidemiological aspects. Elsevier Masson.
- Sebilleau V, Cornut
P, Gambrelle J, Fleury J, Denis P (2008) Epidemiological analysis of ocular
trauma examined in ophthalmic emergencies between March and April 2007, about
1000 cases, Elsevier Masson.
- Seck SM, Gboton
G, Seck CM, Gueye NN, Aml A (2007) Epidemiological and Clinical Aspects of
Severe Ocular Trauma in a Hospital in Dakar. Elsevier Masson, non-series 172.
- Kaimbo WKD, Spileers
W, Missotten L (2002) Traumatic Hyphema by contusion in Zaire. Bull. Soc.
Belgian Ophthalmol 284; 49-53.
- Sidi C, Ducousso
F, Traore L, Momo G, Schemann JF (2000) Retrospective study of IOTA-treated
piercing eye trauma in 180 cases (1998). Medicine of Black Africa 47: 285-289.
- Beby F, Kodjikian L, Roche O, Donate D,
Kouassi N, et al. (2006) Perforating eye trauma in children: a retrospective
study of 57 cases. French ophthalmology journal 29: 20-23.
- Yaya G, Bobossi G, Gaudeuille A (2005) Eye trauma in children aged 0-15 years: epidemiological and clinical aspects at Bangui National Hospital. French Journal of Ophthalmology 28: 708-712.