Prevalence and Possible Surgical Intervention of Ear, Nose and Throat Diseases in Local Population of Pakistan
Muhammad Tariq Rafi1,3, Shafaque
Mehboob1, Khalid Aftab2*, Zafar Said Saify1, Uneeba Rehman3
1Jinnah Sindh Medical
University, Karachi-Pakistan
2Department of Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Islam Medical and
Dental College, Sialkot-Pakistan
3Jinnah Post Medical College, Karachi-Pakistan
*Corresponding author: Khalid Aftab, Department
of Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Islam Medical and Dental College,
Sialkot-Pakistan. Tel: +923335632975; Email: aftabk@cyber.net.pk
Received Date: 29 July, 2017; Accepted Date: 03 August,
2017; Accepted Date: 11
August, 2017
Objective: To
study the prevalence of ear, nose and throat diseases and their possible
surgical intervention in local population of Pakistan.
Methodology: 1,382
patients from the department of ear, nose and throat surgery from
January-December 2016 were selected in this retrospective study. The age,
gender, presenting complains with history, diagnosis and operative procedures
were noted. These patients were divided into three groups according to the
involvement of Otorhinolaryngological anatomical region. Analysis of the data
was performed using SPSS version 16 and results are expressed in numbers or
percentages.
Results: The age
ranges of patients were one year to 85 years with maximum age group of 10-19
years. There were 58.82% males and 41.46% were females. Patients with head/
neck diseases were 42.15%, with nasal distress were 29.01%, with ear problems
16.71% and with oral disorders were 12.22%, therefore, the most commonly
adopted methods were removal of tumor / polyps, tonsillectomy and
mastoidectomy.
Conclusion: Ear
diseases were the most found in the current study and oral cavity lesions being
the least common. The peak age was 10-19 years. There is a need of man power
and implantation of new techniques.
Keywords: Otorhinolaryngological
(ORL) Diseases; Retrospective Study; Prevalence; Surgical; Intervention
1. Introduction
Wide varieties of Ear, Nose and Throat diseases and limited facilities are always one of the leading challenges for health care administrators and providers in under developed countries like Pakistan [1-2]. The spectrum of these disorders displays great variation from one community to another be it congenital or acquired [3]. Proper knowledge and treatment/surgical intervention in time may let a patient to lead quality life without social embarrassment and economic losses due to aesthetic problem of the face or co-morbidities associated with impairment physiologic functions of hearing and breathing [4]. Ear infection is one of the most prevalent diseases specially in pediatric population and may badly effect the speech development due to conductive and sensorineural hearing loss as well as behavioral responses in children if persist for longer period of time usually caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus [5-11]. Several studies conducted in different parts of the world including Europe and Asian countries reveals the risk factors associated with the middle ear infection strongly correlate this with poor socioeconomic status, improper ventilation, smoking and low birth weight etc. [12-17].
Acute sinusitis may lead to the chronic pathology, if lasts for couple of month with persistent symptoms and signs altering CT scan [18-20]. It is prevalent up to 14% of the global population in USA but in the case of pediatric patients, the condition is further exaggerated and may reach to 32%. If economic burden is taken under consideration, only in USA 24 million patients received medical aid for the same problem in 1992 that cost $200 million. In the case of children less than 8, rate is much higher [21]. When multivariate analysis was carried out in a study, not only occupational or inheritance factors proved to be affected but some medications such as corticosteroids and local decongestants were also included among risk factors [22-26].
Oral cancer damaging oropharynx cavity arising as the most prevalent type of carcinoma all over the world, having almost the same factors in all populations such as tobacco and alcohol with a new thread of Human Papillomavirus (HPV) including Pakistan involving tonsil, base of the tongue, and other parts of the pharynx [28-34].
The main objective of the current study is to provide a data based information reflecting the magnitude of otalaryngological disorders or distress with the possible surgical management in local population of Pakistan to guide health policy makers of the respective field for the implementation of modified planning.
2. Patients and Methods
2.1. Inclusion Criteria: patients with chronic signs and symptoms that cannot be managed without surgical intervention, during the period January 2016 to December 2016 with the age 0 to 85 years of both the gender.
2.2. Exclusion Criteria: neonates, patients with acute diseases of e.n.t. that can be managed at home, other than 2016 calendar year or having any diseases other than ENT.
This is a retrospective study of patients records in January 2016 to December 2016 conducted in a public tertiary care hospital regarding the type of otorhinolaryngological diseases. All the patients who were admitted in the ear, nose and throat department for surgical intervention met, the inclusion criteria, were included in the study. Demographic data showing age gender and complain of the disease and its duration along with socioeconomic status of the patients was also taken under consideration. Patients aged between 1-85 years of both the gender belonging to the different parts of the country visited the hospital during the mentioned period.
Statistical analysis was done for the collected data interpretation using descriptive analysis with the help of SPSS version 16.0 statistical software. Results are expressed in numbers or percentages and comparison is discussed among the groups.
3. Results
During the study period, as shown in (Table-1 & Figure-1) 1382 patients admitted in Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) department (surgical ward) of a tertiary care hospital. Statistical values presented greater percentage of male patients’ i.e., 58.82% as compare to female 41.46% like many studies conducted in different populations in different part of the world.
The highest percentage of age group 10-19 up to 27.56% is alarming situation for parents to protect their children from infections or allergens leading to e.n.t disorders. Although minimum percentage of 1.51% belong to 70 years or plus patients but the maximum age was of 85 years of two male patients.
According to (Table-2 & Figure-2) most frequently applied surgical technique was with the use of general anesthesia up to 48.98 %, then local anesthesia found i.e., 21.56%, then Fibrotic direct laryngoscopy up to 17.43% and the least was punch biopsy up to 12.01 %.
If prevalence and surgical management is concerned, most of the patients (31.04%) were admitted due to pharyngeal problems, then nasal disorders (29.01%), after that ear problem (16.71%), then oral diseases and finally laryngeal disorders (11.11%) (Table-3 & Figure-3).
Total 169 patients were admitted due to oral growth or lesion (66), cancer (52), tongue tie (31) and other problems (20). In the case disorders , 231 patients were enrolled among them 144 were due to chronic suppurative otitis media, 40 because of cyst or keloid removal, 35 to get rid of foreign particles and 12 were suffering other problems.401 patients were facing the disorders of nose in which maximum number was of angiofebroma either with epistaxis (182) or without epistaxis (30) , then of deviated nasal septum 91300 who underwent septoplasty and the least number of patients with foreign particles for removal, although 16 patients were of different problems. Pharyngeal complains reflecting the disorders of adenoids (570, tonsillitis (234), stridor (80), cancer (42) and overgrowth in the region (11). In the case of thyroid, 53 cases were reported who subjected to lobectomy. Laryngeal biopsy or removal of carcinogenic area was confirmed in 72 patients.
The provided data of e.n.t. diseases of the whole mentioned year in the current study reflect not just the spectrum of otalaryngological distress but in-depth of surgical interventions using different techniques too. These heavy expenses not only due to recurrent and metastatic conditions but even because of presence of foreign particles in nasal, ear or airway path is an alarming situation for the parents, health establishments and also for general public to launch awareness programs and better policies [28].
There were more male patients as compare to the female who admitted the ward to seek aid and the maximum of teenage. Most of the cases strongly correlate to the socio-economic status and tropical region of the patients. This study is agreed with the research conducted by A. J Fasunla M. Samdi and O. G. Nwaorgu [36].
As far as combined cases of pharynx and larynx are considered, it contributes the maximum 42.15% of the total which is huge, among them tonsillitis aroused as the most common.
Irrespective to the anatomical site, if only local aggressive vascular tumor (be it benign or malignant) plus biopsy for its confirmation is focused, 499 out of 1382 constitute 32.48% of the whole year e.n.t incidences. In several evidence based research articles ear diseases usually infections are reported maximum among the e.n.t. distress but unfortunately in our population gutka chewing is found to exaggerate the prevalence of squamous cell carcinoma which is already accounting the head and neck malignancy at the highest level [35].
80 patients with Strider underwent tracheostomy for proper and safe mechanical ventilation. In addition to this, 53 patients, suffering from cold nodules were subjected to lobectomy from different parts of the country once again focusing our attention to provide clean and safe water to nip in the bud of this disease cause.
Out of 401 patients from nasal disorders, 182 got angiofebroma with epistaxis and 30 without it. Septoplasty was the most commonly employed method for deviated nasal septum.
Chronic superlative otitis media was the leading ear diseases which affected 144 patients. Usually in first decade of life, ear infections badly influence life style but if it is left untreated, second decade become worsen due to this chronic infection or may be because of its late consequences such as hear loss or throat or nasal obstructions [36].
It’s time to establish public specially parents awareness programs such as neonatal early hearing diagnosis and rehabilitation programs to save our energy, economy and the most importantly people.
Figure 1: Age Distribution of E.N.T disorders.
Figure 2: Adopted Surgical Technique.
Figure 3: Ear, Nose and Throat Orders/Surgical Management Distribution
Discussion.
Age in years |
Male (numbers) |
Female (numbers) |
Total Numbers |
Percentage/ frequencies of total (%) |
0-9 |
89 |
67 |
156 |
11.28 |
10-19 |
215 |
166 |
381 |
27.56 |
20-29 |
147 |
108 |
255 |
18.45 |
30-39 |
106 |
86 |
192 |
13.89 |
40-49 |
123 |
75 |
198 |
14.32 |
50-59 |
59 |
38 |
97 |
7.01 |
60-69 |
58 |
28 |
86 |
6.22 |
70-onward |
16 |
5 |
20 |
1.14 |
Total % |
58.82% |
41.46% |
1382 |
100% |
Age in years |
Male (numbers) |
Female (numbers) |
Total Numbers |
Percentage/ frequencies of total (%) |
0-9 |
89 |
67 |
156 |
11.28 |
10-19 |
215 |
166 |
381 |
27.56 |
20-29 |
147 |
108 |
255 |
18.45 |
30-39 |
106 |
86 |
192 |
13.89 |
40-49 |
123 |
75 |
198 |
14.32 |
50-59 |
59 |
38 |
97 |
7.01 |
60-69 |
58 |
28 |
86 |
6.22 |
70-onward |
16 |
5 |
20 |
1.14 |
Total % |
58.82% |
41.46% |
1382 |
100% |
Table 1: Age Distribution of E.N.T disorders.
Technique used |
Numbers |
Percentage |
Local anesthesia |
298 |
21.56 |
General anesthesia |
677 |
48.98 |
Punch biopsy |
166 |
12.01 |
Fiberoptic direct laryngoscopy |
241 |
17.43 |
Total |
1,382 |
100.00 |
Table 2: Adopted Surgical Technique.
|
Anatomical region |
Numbers |
Frequency (%) |
A |
ORAL |
|
12.22% (out of 1382) |
|
Oral growth / lesion |
66 |
9.05 (out of 169) |
|
Cancer |
52 |
30.7 (out of 169) |
|
Tongue tie |
31 |
18.34 (out of 169) |
|
Others |
20 |
11.83 (out of 169) |
|
Total |
169 |
|
B |
EAR |
|
16.71 (out of 1382) |
|
CSOM / Mastoidectomy |
144 |
62.33 (out of 231) |
|
Cyst /keloid |
40 |
17.31 (out of 231) |
|
F.B |
35 |
14.9 (out of 231) |
|
Others |
12 |
5.19 (out of 231) |
|
Total |
231 |
|
C |
NOSE |
|
29.01 (out of 1382) |
|
Angiofebroma with epistaxis |
182 |
45.38 (out of 401) |
|
D.N.S / Septoplasty |
130 |
32.41 (out of 401) |
|
Nasopharyngeal growth |
30 |
7.48 (out of 401) |
|
F.B |
43 |
10.72 (out of 401) |
|
OTHERS |
16 |
3.99 (out of 401) |
|
Total |
401 |
|
D |
NECK |
|
42.15% (out of 1382) |
|
PHARYNX |
|
31.04 (out of 1382) |
|
Adenoids |
57 |
13.28 (out of 429) |
|
Tonsillitis |
234 |
54.54 (out of 429) |
|
Stridor / tracheotomy |
80 |
18.6 (out of 429) |
|
Growth |
11 |
2.56 (out of 429) |
|
Vocal cord cancer |
47 |
10.9 (out of 429) |
|
Total |
429 |
|
|
LARYNX |
|
11.11(out of 1382) |
|
Lobectomy |
53 |
34.64 (out of 153) |
|
Biopsy/ cancers |
72 |
47.05 (out of 153) |
|
Others |
28 |
18.30 (out of 153) |
|
Total |
153 |
|
Table 3: Ear, Nose and Throat Orders/Surgical Management Distribution.
4. Famuyiwa OO,
Olorunshola DA, Derin A (1998) Some family factors in sickle cell anemia in
Lagos, Nigeria. Nig Med Practitioner 35: 70-73.
21. DeGroot RRM, Zanten VME
(1993) Otorhinolaryngology in outline 1984–1993. SIG Health
Care Information, Utrecht: 1-24.
23. Berendes J, Link
JR, Zöllner FAlbeggerKW, Banale Entzüngender Nase under
Nasenbenhölen. In: Hals, Nasen-, OhrenHeilkunde in Praxis und
Klinik. Band I. Obere und untere
Luftwege. eds Berendes J, Link JR, Zöllner F,
G Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart: 11.1-11.32.
24. Kennedy DW (1994)
Sinus diseases: guide to first-line management. Health Communications,
Deerfield Beach, Florida: 12.
25. Beauvillain de
Montreuil C, Aubert P, Perahia M, et al. (1998)
Facteurs de risque de sinusite chronique. J Franç ORL 47: 261-264.
26. Savolainen S (1989) Allergy in
patients with acute maxillary sinusitis. Allergy 44: 116-122.