Repair of Inguinal Hernia in an Ambulatory Way
Pedro
Rolando Lòpez Rodrìguez1, Olga Caridad Leòn
Gonzalez2, Jorge Satorre Rocha2, Eduardo Castillo Garcia3, Luis Manuel Danta Fundora3, Elisa Puentes Rizo4, Angelica Lais Ceruto Ortiz5
1Consultant Professor in General Surgery,
Auxiliary Researcher, General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera",
Havana, Cuba
2Auxiliary Assistant in General Surgery,
Auxiliary Researcher, General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera",
Havana, Cuba
3Assistant Professor in General Surgery,
Aggregate Investigator, General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera",
Havana, Cuba
4Auxiliary Teacher in MGI, Associate
Researcher, General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera", Havana, Cuba
5Resident first year in General Surgery,
General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera", Havana, Cuba
*Corresponding author: Pedro Rolando Lòpez
Rodrìguez, Consultant
Professor in General Surgery, Auxiliary Researcher, General Teaching Hospital
"Enrique Cabrera", Havana, Cuba. Email: pedro.rolando.lopez42@gmail.com/lopezp@infomed.sld.cu
Received Date: 21 June, 2019; Accepted Date: 25 July, 2019; Published Date: 02 August, 2019
Citation: Rodrìguez PRL, Gonzalez OCL, Rocha JS,
Garcia EC, Fundora LMD, et al. (2019) Repair of Inguinal Hernia in An
Ambulatory Way. J Anesth Surg Rep: JASR-113. DOI: 10.29011/JASR-113.100013
Introduction:
the surgical treatment of inguinal hernia has increased in the last decade and
its prevalence is not known.
Objective:
to evaluate the results of ambulatory surgical treatment of this entity from
January 2009 to December 2018.
Methods:
an observational, descriptive and prospective study of 380 patients diagnosed
with inguinal hernia was performed, which were operated on an outpatient basis
in the General Teaching Hospital "Enrique Cabrera" from January 2009
to December 2018. Patients were included emergency operated.
Results:
the highest incidence of inguinal hernia was found between the ages of 60 and
80 years. Indirect right inguinal hernia appeared more frequently. Desarda's
anatomic surgical technique was the most applied in 410 (54%) of the cases and
Lichtenstein's hernioplasty with 224 (29.4%) followed in frequency. There was a
total of 5 (0.6%) recurrences. Local anesthesia was applied in 609 (90.8%) of
the patients, on an outpatient basis they were 100%. The total complications
were 31 (4.0%).
Conclusions:
surgical treatment of inguinal hernia on an outpatient basis is an appropriate
process. Ensures the comfort of patients, reduces the risk of hospital
infection, reduces waiting lists and hospital costs.
Keywords: Hospital Costs; Inguinal
Hernia; Outpatient Treatment
1. Introduction
The
inguinal hernia is known since man adopted the erect position, so it is one of
the most frequent conditions. Its history is as old as humanity itself. It is a
topic of interest not only for historians, but for compulsory knowledge for
anatomists and surgeons. The first description of hernia reduction dates back
to the time of Hammurabi in the Egyptian papyri [1].
According to the Ebers Papyrus, dating from 1560 BC, the hernia is a tumor in
the genitals in which the intestines move. It is the protrusion of an organ of
the abdominal cavity through a natural or acquired orifice. Hesinten, in 1794,
establishes a differentiation between hernias treated by direct and indirect
inguinal sacs. It is important to point out that this had already been
demonstrated by Cospar Stromary in 1599, who insisted on the futility of
sacrificing the testicle in direct hernias [2].
In
1804, Cospar described the transverse fascia and pointed out that this layer
and not the peritoneum and external oblique aponeurysis was the main barrier to
avoid herniation. He also defined direct hernia as a defect that occurs through
the Hesselbach triangle [3]. With the passing of
time came the modern era of hernia surgery, which began with the discovery of
antisepsis by Lister, studies on anesthesia, knowledge of the normal physiology
of the inguinofemoral region, the introduction of antibiotics and the best
understanding of the tissue repair and healing process. Everything was linked
to the appearance of better surgical methods which is evidenced by the work of
Henry and Marcy in the USA. UU and of E. Bassini in Italy [4]. We must point out that from the second half of
the eighties a new era began, characterized by the use of prosthetic meshes and
patches with which better results are obtained in this surgery. Among the
materials used is polypropylene, which is biocompatible with high tensile
strength, flexible, impermeable to water and resistant to high temperatures,
which makes it sterilizable [5].
The
application of ambulatory surgery has the following advantages: it only alters
the patient's way of life, which receives more individual attention; the
anxiety of the patient is attenuated; costs are reduced; decreases the risk of
hospital infection and disability; as well as facilitates the return to work.
All this contributes to the improvement of the quality of the services provided
to achieve an excellent service. One of the most important aspects of this type
of surgery is the application of local anesthesia that improves the
cost-benefit ratio of the procedure, decreases the use of hospital beds and
allows the patient's collaboration if necessary. The aim of this study is to evaluate
the results of outpatient surgical treatment of this entity from January 2009
to December 2018.
2. Methods
A
cross-sectional, retrospective, descriptive observational study of patients
operated out of inguinal hernia was performed in the surgery service of the
"Enrique Cabrera" General Teaching Hospital in the period from
January 2009 to December 2018. The universe consisted of patients operated on
inguinal hernia in the surgery service of the General Teaching Hospital
"Enrique Cabrera" from January 2009 to December 2018. The sample
consisted of patients operated on inguinal hernia on an outpatient basis by the
Group. Basic Work (GBT) No. 1 in the surgery service of said hospital in the
aforementioned period. This study included all patients aged 18 years or older,
ASA III or lower risk of anesthesia, obesity not over 50% overweight and
carriers of the disease under study. Patients with associated, decompensated
and overweight diseases greater than 50% of their body weight were excluded.
The principles related to the code of ethics were followed, according to the
Helsinki declaration. The security and confidentiality of the information was
guaranteed.
3. Results
It
is observed that the most frequent location of the inguinal hernia was the
right side with 384 patients for the (50.6%) of the total, of which 66.3, were
indirect. The average age of the patients included in the study was 57.4 years.
There were five recurrent hernias (0.6%). According to the Nyhus
classification, there were a total of 760 patients with hernias belonging to
types II and III
b, which were the most frequent (Table 1).
The
operative techniques most used in inguinal hernias are shown in Table 2. Non-prosthetic techniques were applied and of
these the most performed was the Mohan P. Desarda technique in 410 patients
(54.0%). Within the prosthetic techniques the most applied was that of
Lichtenstein, in 224 patients (29.04%).
Table 3 shows the most used aesthetic
procedures. Local anesthesia was applied in 690 patients (90.8%) of the total,
followed by spinal anesthesia or spinal anesthesia in 66 patients (8.8%).
The
associated diseases are shown in Table 4, with
the prevalence of arterial hypertension 145 patients (19.0%) and the conditions
associated with umbilical hernia with 10 patients (1.3%).
The Table 5 shows the distribution of complications in
patients undergoing local anesthesia in the period from January 2009 to
December 2018, at the "Enrique Cabrera" General Teaching Hospital.
It
is observed that the seroma was the complication that most frequently presented
9 patients (1.1), followed by infection of the surgical site 8 patients (1.0)
and in total 31 complicated patients (4.0). The cost of admission per day and
on an outpatient basis result in significant savings and favour the efficiency
and well-being of our patients, returning to the family environment and significant
financial savings are obtained in hospital institutions, so this system should
be developed
4. Discussion
The
results obtained in this series are consistent with those obtained by different
authors and differ from others who point out the primacy of inguinal hernia in
younger patients. There was predominance of males, results similar to those
referred in several studies on the subject [6,7]
According to experts in the field, up to 25% of males and only 2% of females
will develop inguinal hernia at some point in their life. This fact has been
related to the descent of the testicle, with a greater thickness of the
spermatic cord and with a lower obliquity of the inguinal canal in man. In the
opinion of the authors, who share the Goderich criterion [8], when other conditions are concomitant, patients
should be treated before having herniorrhaphy to avoid postoperative discomfort
and the increase in the recurrence rate. There are also criteria that the
McBurney incision during appendectomy is related to the appearance of inguinal
hernia. In the present work the ages ranged between 60 and 80 years, which is
similar to the literature reviewed. The right inguinal hernia was the most
frequent, as well as the indirect variety on both sides. It was also observed
that the highest number of hernias corresponded to variety II, from the Nyhus classification [9], (144 patients) and variety III b (103 patients). Every surgeon who frequently
intervenes in patients with a hernia of the inguinal region knows that there are
innumerable surgical techniques, to which advantages and disadvantages are
indicated. The purpose is to reduce complications and, above all, to avoid
recurrences [10]. There are so-called classical
(anatomical) techniques that repair the defect of the inguinal wall with the
patient's own tissues and, the so-called prosthetic techniques, which use
synthetic materials that have had a great development in recent decades and
whose application always leads to the same purposes as anatomical.
It
was observed that the most used anatomical technique was that of Mohan P.
Desarda, followed by the Lichtenstein technique. For some years now, a basic
working group of our surgical service has applied the anatomical technique of
Professor Desarda and has obtained good results. This technique, as pointed out
by its creator, has some advantages, among which are its easy learning and
execution, available to residents and surgeons not specialized in the treatment
of this disease [11,12]. The technique provides
a posterior wall of the canal Strong inguinal, mobile and physiologically
active. When not using the mesh (foreign body) the fibrosis is minimal or does
not exist, there is no rejection to foreign body and the postoperative pain on
the fifth day of the operation is less than with the techniques that use
prosthesis. With the application of local anesthesia, to carry out the
outpatient procedure in these patients, the complications were minimal [13,14]. By carefully analysing the number of
recurrences and the level of preparation of the acting surgeon, it was found
that all patients operated by residents were helped by specialists, who correct
the possible defects of the operative procedure, this contributes to the
technical improvement and the increase of skills and skills during the surgical
act. In Cuba, this has greater relevance, since the teaching care system
guarantees the integral surgical training of the resident, an aspect not
comparable with what is referred to in the international medical bibliography,
where this centralization does not exist [15-17].
In
this series there were no deaths. None of the operated patients had the need to
change their occupation, or difficulty to get into their job before 60 days. It
is important to highlight the late complications of this procedure, such as the
rejection of the bio prosthesis and the appearance of fistulas and granulomas. We
must point out that in this centre the various techniques of hernia repair,
facial and aponeurotic are applied, with the use of prosthetic meshes or
without these, with good results, especially in the repair of hernias with
tension-free facial techniques, since anatomically it is more physiological,
compared at the same time, with national and international studies [18]. Taking into account the large number of patients
operated during the study period, the savings contributed to the hospital by
the reduction of occupied beds, the decrease in the cost of materials and
medicines, the faster recovery of patients and the incorporation into their
social environment and labour. It is concluded that outpatient surgery with
local anesthesia plus sedation is a beneficial method for patients and hospital
institutions and this is shown in the results in this case [19-22].
Conflicts of Interest:
The authors do not declare having conflicts of interest.
Sex |
No |
% |
Female |
92 |
12.1 |
Male |
668 |
87.9 |
Location |
||
Right |
384 |
50.6 |
Left |
286 |
37.6 |
Bilateral |
90 |
11.8 |
Variety |
||
Indirect |
504 |
66.3 |
Direct |
224 |
29.4 |
Mixed |
32 |
4.3 |
Classification of Nyhus |
||
Type I |
0 |
- |
Type II |
288 |
37.8 |
Type IIIa |
196 |
25.7 |
Type IIIb |
206 |
27.2 |
Type IIIc |
0 |
- |
Type IV |
70 |
9.3 |
Techniques |
No |
% |
Recurrence |
% |
Shouldice |
6 |
0.7 |
|
|
Zimmerman I |
10 |
1.3 |
|
|
Madden |
8 |
1.0 |
1 |
12.5 |
Mc Vay |
20 |
2.6 |
|
|
Goderiche |
8 |
1.0 |
1 |
12.5 |
Bassini |
10 |
1.3 |
|
|
Camayd |
2 |
0.2 |
|
|
Lotheissen Mc Vay |
6 |
0.7 |
|
|
Halsted |
6 |
0.7 |
|
|
Desarda |
410 |
54.0 |
2 |
0.4 |
Plug de Rutkow |
2 |
0.2 |
|
|
Marcy |
12 |
1.5 |
|
|
Rives |
22 |
9.8 |
|
|
Lichtenstein |
224 |
29.4 |
1 |
0.4 |
Rutkow-Robbins |
8 |
1.0 |
|
|
Abraham |
0 |
- |
|
|
Zimmerman II |
6 |
0.7 |
|
|
Total |
760 |
100.0 |
5 |
0.6 |
Procedures |
No |
% |
Local Anesthesia |
690 |
90.8 |
Spinal Anesthesia |
66 |
8.8 |
General and Endotracheal Anesthesia |
2 |
0.2 |
Acupuncture Anesthesia |
0 |
- |
Peridural Anesthesia |
0 |
- |
General Endovenous Anesthesia |
2 |
0.2 |
Total |
760 |
100.0 |
Associated Diseases and Associated Conditions |
No |
% |
Ischemic Cardiopathy |
27 |
3.5 |
Arterial Hypertension |
145 |
19.0 |
Diabetes Mellitus |
28 |
3.6 |
Umbilical Herniorraphy |
10 |
1.3 |
Femoral Herniorraphy |
4 |
0.5 |
Incisional Herniorraphy |
2 |
0.2 |
Eversiòn of Vaginal |
2 |
0.2 |
Total |
218 |
28.6 |
Complications |
No |
% |
Seromas |
9 |
1.1 |
Recurrences |
5 |
0.6 |
Hematomas |
3 |
0.3 |
Orchitis |
5 |
0.6 |
Bladder Piercing |
1 |
0.1 |
Infection of the surgical site |
8 |
1.1 |
Total |
31 |
4.0 |
- Borquez
P, Garridol Manterola C, Pena P, Schlageter C, Orellana J, et al. (2010) Estudio
de fibras colágenas y elástica del tejido
conjuntivo de pacientes con y sin hernia inguinal primaria. Rev Med Chile 131: 1273-1279.
- Rodríguez Ortega MF, Cardenas-Martinez G, Lopez-Castaneda
H (2003) Evolución histórica
del tratamiento de la hernia inguinal. Cirugía y
Cirujanos 71: 245-251.
- Woods BB, Neumayer L (2010)
Open repairof inguinal hernia:en evidence-based review. Surg Clin North Am 88: 139-155.
- Armas
Pérez BA, Reyes Balseiro ES, Dumenigo Area O,
González Monacal OR (2009) Hernias inguinales
bilaterales operadas con anestesia local mediante hernioplastia de Lichtenstein.
Rev Cubana Cir 48.
- Lòpez
Rodrìguez PR, Pol Herrera PG, Leòn Gonzàlez OC, Satorre
Rocha JA, Garcia Castillo E (2016) Tratamiento quirùrgico
ambulatoria en pacientes con hernia inguinal 55.
- Magdaleno
Garcia M, Robles Placencio J, Melendes Delgado MD (2017) Factores relacionados
con el alta precoz tras la reparación de hernia
inguinal. CIR MAY AMB 22: 3-9.
- Doménico Arias O, de Armas Pérez
B, Martínez Ferra G, Gil Hernández A (2007) Hernioplastia inguinal del
Lichtenstein: la mejor opción. Rev Cubana Cir 46:
28-33.
- Goderich
Lalan JM (2003) Herniorrafia inguinal por sobrecapa de fascia transversalis.
Rev Cubana Cir.
- van ven RN, van Wessem KJ,
Halm JA, Simona MP, Plaiser PW, et al. (2007) Patent process us vaginalis in
the adult as a risk factor for the occurrence of indirect inguinal hernias. Surg
Endosc 21: 202-205.
- Abraham
Arap J (2009) Hernias inguinales y crurales (hernia de la ingle). Rev Cubana
Cir 48.
- Abraham
Arap JF, Mederos Curbelo ON, García Gutiérrez A (2009) Características
generales de las hernias abdominales externas. In: García
Gutiérrez A, Pardo Gómez
G. Cirugía. Tomo 3. La Habana: Editorial
Ciencias Médicas Pg No: 410.
- Morales
Conde S, Barreiro Morandeira F (2009) Cirugía de
la hernia: nuevos conceptos, nuevas perspectivas. Cir Esp 83:165-166.
- López Rodríguez P, Pol
Herrera P, León González
O, Muñoz Torres JC (2010) Dolor y costos
hospitalarios en la reparación de la hernia inguinal primaria: Lichtenstein
frente a Desarda. Rev Cubana Cir 49.
- Maraboto
AC (2010) Manejo anestésico del paciente que será sometido a una hernioplastia. México, DF: El Manual
Moderno Pg No: 93-101.
- Medical Research Council
Laparoscopic Groin Hernia Trial Group (2010) Cost-utility analysis of open
versus laparoscopic groin hernia repair: results from a multicenter randomized
clinical trial. Br J Surg. 88: 653-661.
- Butte
JM, León F, van Sint Jan N, Hevia C, Zúñiga A, et al. (2010) Hernioplastia inguinal con
técnica Prolene hernia system. Evaluación de los resultados a largo plazo. Rev
Chl Cir 59: 421-424.
- Arowolo OA, Agbakwuru EA,
Adisa AO, Lawal OO, Ibrahim MH, (2011) Evaluation of tension-free mesh inguinal
hernia repair in Nigeria: a preliminary report. West Afr J Med 30: 110-113.
- Desarda MP
(2009) Comparative study of mesh repair in a set-up of a district hospital in
India. Centr Afric Journ Surg 11: 1-6.
- Desarda
MP (2009) No mesh inguinal hernia repairs with continuous absorbable sutures: A
dream or reality? (A study of 229 patients). The Saudi Journal of
Gastroenterology 14: 122-127.
- López Rodríguez PR, Pol
Herrera P, León González
OC, Satorre Arocha J (2013) Nuestra experiencia de diez años con la
herniorrafia de Mohan P. Desarda. Rev Cub Cir 52: 1-5.
- Recart
A (2017) Cirugìa mayor ambulatoria. Una nueva
forma de la medicina quirúrgica. Rev Med Clin
Las Condes 28: 649-812.
- Capitan
Valvay JM, Gonzalez Vinagre S, Barreiro Morandeira F (2018) Cirugìa mayor ambulatoria: donde estamos y a donde vamos
Rev Española Cir 96: 1-2.