The Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS®) Program in Trinidad and Tobago Positively Impacts Trauma Education and Care in the Caribbean
Jameel Ali1, Navin Sookar1*,
Rasheed Adam2, Henry Bedaysie2, Ian Pierre2,
Sushilla Maharaj2, Ernest Ali3, Rosanna Robinson4,
Kenneth John5, Grace Herrera
Fernandez6, Marsha Bedaysie7
1Department of Women’s Health, St. James Medical
Complex, Trinidad and Tobago
2Society of Surgeons of Trinidad and Tobago, Trinidad
and Tobago
3ATLS
Coordinator, Port of Spain General Hospital, Trinidad and Tobago
4ATLS
Coordinator, San Fernando General Hospital, Trinidad and Tobago
5St.
John Ambulance, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
6ATLS
Coordinator, Costa Rica
7ATLS
Coordinator, Trinidad and Tobago
*Corresponding author: Navin Sookar, Department of Women’s Health, St. James Medical Complex, 112 Western Main Road, St. James, Trinidad and Tobago. Tel: +18686886941; Email: navin_shawn@hotmail.com
Received Date: 11 August, 2018; Accepted Date:
27 August, 2018; Published Date: 03 September, 2018
Citation: Ali J, Sookar N, Adam R, Bedaysie H, Pierre I, et al. (2018) The Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS®) Program in Trinidad and Tobago Positively Impacts Trauma Education and Care in the Caribbean. J Orthop Res Ther 2018: 1108. DOI: 10.29011/2575-8241.001108
The Advanced Trauma life support (ATLS) program was introduced in Trinidad and Tobago as the first program outside North America in 1986. This was the beginning of the International promulgation program through which over 2 million doctors have been trained internationally. In Trinidad and Tobago, the program is still very active and has spawned many other trauma education programs in Trinidad and the rest of Caribbean Islands including development of Ambulance systems training, prehospital trauma training, disaster management and rural trauma course teaching. In this report, we describe the development and impact of these programs in Trinidad and Tobago and their extension to other islands of the Caribbean through faculty from Trinidad and Tobago We describe these programs in greater detail outlining the specific programs in each of the Caribbean islands. These programs have provided a strong bond among physicians interested in trauma care in the Caribbean
Keywords: Advanced
Trauma life support (ATLS); Impact of ATLS; Pre-Hospital Trauma Life Support
(PHTLS); Rural Trauma Team Development Course (RTTDC); Trauma Evaluation and
Management (TEAM); Trauma Training
3. Introduction
The
Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS) program was developed through the
recognition of the need for trauma training among primary care physicians in
North America, where like most of the world, trauma continues to be the leading
cause of death among individuals less than 40 years of age [1]. The original ATLS program was
initiated in the late 1970’s in Nebraska and soon became adopted by the American
College of Surgeons Committee on Trauma [2]. It
was then introduced throughout the US and Canada after which it was initiated
in Trinidad and Tobago in 1986. The impact of the program on trauma outcomes in
Trinidad and Tobago is reported including the effect on trauma education [3]. The mortality decreased two-fold following ATLS
teaching among physicians in the main trauma referral hospitals in Trinidad and
Tobago. However, overall trauma mortality in the country as a whole was unaffected
due to the large percentage of patients dying in the prehospital setting from
trauma [4]. This prompted the introduction of
the Pre-Hospital Trauma Life Support (PHTLS) course which led to improvement in
overall trauma mortality in Trinidad and Tobago [5].
Other trauma education programs in Trinidad and Tobago include the Rural Trauma Team Development Course (RTTDC), the Disaster Management program, the Trauma Evaluation and Management (TEAM) program for medical student in their senior years and first responder trauma programs. The ATLS program stimulated the development of an ambulance training program in Trinidad and Tobago. Soon thereafter, the faculty from Trinidad and Tobago was invited to conduct ATLS programs in Jamaica where other programs including the TEAM program were conducted [5]. In this report, we chronicle the development of trauma training programs in adjacent islands in the Caribbean, detailing the type and number of programs in each island. We also describe the influence of the Trinidad and Tobago Faculty in the dissemination of these programs as well as the effect on trauma education and trauma outcome [6].
4. Methods
We assessed trauma education program evolution in Trinidad Tobago and the rest of the Caribbean by reporting on the specific programs introduced into the Caribbean islands by the Trinidad and Tobago faculty. Programs in Trinidad, Grenada, Jamaica and Barbados as well as their impact on ambulance system development and training of participants from other islands that do not have their own trauma training programs, are outlined. The results are grouped according to individual island trauma training program activities
5.
Results
5.1. Trinidad and Tobago
·
Using the ATLS program as a model, the faculty
from Trinidad and Tobago coordinated the development of ambulances with
communication systems. A total of 125 ambulances (National Ambulance Service
45; Government 20; Regional Health 20; Private including Red Cross 40) were
equipped, compared to about 25, ten years previously.
·
ATLS: 103 courses were conducted (16-32
participants per course) for a total of 2287 physician trained. 550 nurses
audited the ATLS provider course in Trinidad and Tobago. 162 physicians were also
trained in ATLS from Barbados, Guyana, Antigua, Dominica, Bahamas, St. Lucia,
Suriname. Curacao and Aruba at the Trinidad sites.
·
PHTLS: 62 courses were conducted in which
1200 participants were trained since its inception.
·
TEAM: This program is aimed at training
senior medical students in the concepts of trauma resuscitation based on the
ATLS course. TEAM was
started in 2001 with 100-200 trained per year. This program has shown improved
MCQ performance not only in Trinidad and Tobago but also in 6 other countries [7,8] (Figure 1).
· RTTDC: This program is geared towards applying ATLS concepts in low resource clinical settings. Two courses were conducted with 30 physicians trained in Trinidad.
The
ATLS program was associated with a decrease in overall mortality among all
trauma patients (Table 1) and this was found
across all Injury Severity Scores (ISS) (Table 2). This
was due to demonstrated increase in overall implementation of prehospital
resuscitative manoeuvres (Figure 2) and
increased implementation of resuscitative manoeuvres specifically in the
emergency department (Figure 3) [9].
5.1. Grenada
·
The ATLS program in Grenada, although
funded by St George’s University, was conducted by the faculty from Trinidad
and Tobago: 20 ATLS Courses were conducted in which 346 physicians were
trained. The physicians trained also included those providing trauma care while
residing in Grenada having moved there from St. Vincent, Africa, India and the
Middle East. 165 nurses also audited the ATLS provider courses in Grenada.
·
PHTLS: 18 courses have been conducted, and
256 participants were trained.
·
RTTDC: 4 courses have been conducted with
48 participants trained.
· TEAM: An annual course for over 250 participants was conducted by the Trinidad and Tobago faculty but was discontinued 5 years ago. This was replaced by the International Trauma Life Support (ITLS) course which is coordinated by the St. George’s University faculty.
5.2. Jamaica
ATLS: The Trinidad and Tobago faculty conducted 9 courses from 2001-2004, training 169 ATLS physicians as instructors and providers, ATLS coordinators and 72 nurse auditors. The course required re-establishment on two separate occasions due to change of leadership, lack of funding and decreased activity.
5.3. Barbados
In 1994, a PHTLS course was conducted for 14 instructors and then in 2009 for 8 instructors. This course was stopped due to lack of funding.
6. Discussion
As indicated worldwide, trauma is the leading cause of
death among young individuals. The ATLS course introduced in Trinidad and
Tobago in 1986 was associated with a significant decrease in trauma mortality
due to improved skills among physicians and paramedical personnel in the
hospital and pre-hospital setting. Adherence to ATLS principles has been useful
in developing ambulance systems in Trinidad and Tobago. ATLS training has been
implemented by the Trinidad and Tobago faculty in other Caribbean islands and
has also been associated with the establishment of other trauma training
programs such as the TEAM program for medical students and the PHTLS for
pre-hospital personnel. Increased implementation of these programs in the
islands of Barbados and Jamaica is desirable but requires additional financial
support from government and other funding agencies. The moving force behind
these efforts in trauma education and trauma care in the Caribbean emanates
from the ATLS faculty of Trinidad and Tobago.
Figure 1: MCQ
trauma scores (%) among medical students before and after the TEAM course in
seven countries, including Trinidad. Trauma MCQ scores increased post TEAM
training in all countries.
Figure 2:
Percentage of Trauma Patients Receiving ATLS Procedures
Overall. ATLS procedures increased overall after ATLS. (IV-established
intravenous access; AIS- Abbreviated injury score).
Figure 3: Percentage of Procedures Administered in the Emergency
Department. There was a significant increase in ATLS procedures conducted
in the Emergency room after ATLS. (IV-established intravenous access; AIS-
Abbreviated injury score).
Figure 4: Trauma
Patient Outcome After the PHTLS Program. Pre PHTLS mortality was unchanged
after the initial improvement post ATLS. There was a further decrease in
mortality after PHTLS for all injury severity scores
|
TOTAL
PATIENTS |
DEATHS |
Pre -
ATLS |
413 |
279 |
Post -
ATLS |
400 |
134 |
Totals |
813 |
413 |
Table 1: Mortality Among
All Trauma Patients. There was an overall
decrease in trauma
mortality after ATLS (4
years pre and 4 years
post ATLS compared).
ISS |
Mortality
Pre (%) |
Mortality
Post (%) |
Odds
Ratio |
Less
than 24 |
47.9 |
16.7 |
4.5 |
24-40 |
91.0 |
71.0 |
1.2 |
41+ |
100 |
100 |
|
1. Ali J.
Fraser Gurd Lecture (2008) The Advanced Trauma Life Support Program. Historical
Perspectives and Future Directions. Journal of Trauma 64: 1149-1158.