The Establishment of Zebrafish Cultivation Method and the Effect of Traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine on its Growth
Xiao-Li
Zhao, Xiao-Mi Yang, Peng Xiao, Xing-Ping He, Jian-Yu Gong, Juehua Yu*, Hai-Jian
Zou*
The
Research Center of Yunnan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Kunming,
Yunnan, People’s Republic of China, China
*Corresponding author(s): Hai-Jian Zou, The
Research Center of Yunnan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Kunming,
Yunnan 650500, People’s Republic of China, China. Email: azouhj99@163.com;
Juehua
Yu, The Research Center of Yunnan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine,
Kunming, Yunnan 650500, People’s Republic of China, China. Email:
juehuayu@yeah.net
Received Date: 27 September,
2018; Accepted Date: 15 October,
2018; Published Date: 23 October,
2018
1. Abstract
1.1. Objective: The aim of this study was to find an appropriate food for zebrafish larval cultivation and analyze the effects of Polygala tenuifolia Willd. (YZ), Semen Ziziphi spinosae (SZR) and fruits of Alpinia oxyphylla Miq (YZR) on the development of the embryonic nervous system.
1.2. Methods: 60 well-developed 4 days postfertilization (dpf) larvae were randomly divided into group I and II (30 tails for each group). Group I was fed Paramecium and group II was fed dried brine shrimp powder. After a 15-day feeding period, the body length and survival rate between the two groups were compared. Then 100 zebrafish eggs were randomly divided into 5 groups, 20 eggs each, and cultured at 28ºC. The negative control group was cultivated in embryo culture medium, the positive control group was cultivated in 0.10 mg/mL folic acid solution, treatment groups were given 0.10 mg/mL water extract of YZ, 0.2 mg/mL water extract of SZR and 0.17 mg/mL water extract of YZR. The formation time and embryonic development of neural plate, nerve tube and brain were observed.
1.3. Results: The death rate larvae in group II at each developmental stage were significantly lower than those of group I (p<0.05), and the growth rate of body length in group II was significantly higher than that of group I. The survival rate of larvae in group II was significantly higher than that of group I (p<0.05) at the 15th day and a specific growth rate (SGR) of 3.20% was observed in group I and 7.25% SGR in group II. The formation times of neural plate, nerve tube and brain of YZR group were shorter than those of the YZ and SZR groups, and significantly different from those of the negative and positive control groups (p<0.01).
1.4. Conclusion: The survival rate and body length growth rate of larvae in group II were significantly higher than those of group I, which suggested that the dried brine shrimp powder could be used as an alternative food for the larvae. YZR treatment was shown to shorten the formation time of the embryonic nervous system, indicating that the water extract of YZR can influence the development of nervous system in the early embryonic stage.
2. Keywords: Zebrafish;
Survival rate; Body length; Nervous system development
3. Introduction
Zebrafish
(Brachydanio rerio) is a common tropical fish in India and Bangladesh.
Zebrafish has high homology to human in the blood, visceral organs, visual
system and central nervous system and other aspects, for up to 87%, and has,
therefore, become another widely recognized vertebrate model animal for
biological research [1,2]. Zebrafish are widely used in the field of drug
development as a model animal because of its advantages such as small size,
high throughput, low breeding cost, short spawning cycle and reliable
experimental output [3]. With the increasing popularity of zebrafish in
research, the successful breeding of zebrafish larvae becomes particularly
important. The choice of food for larvae during the transition from endogenous
nutrition to exogenous nutrition is of particular importance to the survival
and growth of zebrafish [4]. In recent reports, although the Paramecium and
Artemia as general food for zebrafish larvae, and the rotifers, yeasts, egg
yolk granules and pellets are widely used as additional food among Chinese
researchers (4-6). Studies have been performed on the characteristics of these
diets, but overall, the survival rate of larvae remains relatively low. In this
study, based on the previous reports and our experience, improvements of larvae
diet were made to significantly increase the survival rate.
With
the significant improvement in living standards and the growing awareness of
health and disease prevention, drugs or supplements derived from traditional
Chinese herbal medicine (TCM) are gaining popularity [7]. The establishment of
the professional committee of the World Federation of Chinese Medicine
Association of TCM and Supplements in December 2015 boosted the modernization
and globalization of traditional Chinese medicine [8]. According to official
statistics from the China Medicines and Supplements Import and Export Chamber
of Commerce, the imports and exports of drugs and supplements in 2016 amounted
to 103.4 billion U.S. dollars, an increase of 0.73% year-on-year. Medicinal and
edible Chinese herb is an important part of the traditional Chinese medicine,
and all 87 entries of the 2002 "List of Medicinal and Edible Chinese
Herb" from the former Ministry of Health are traditional Chinese herbal
medicine. In-depth study of Chinese herbal medicine not only reflects the
traditional thought of " homology of food and medicine", but also
caters to the recent advocacy to promote health through organic and natural
food choices [9]. In this study, to understand the effects of several
traditional Chinese herbal medicines on the growth and development of
zebrafish, folic acid was selected as a positive control and the embryo culture
medium as a negative control, with Polygala tenuifolia Willd. (YZ), Semen
Ziziphi spinosae (Suanzaoren in Chinese, SZR) and Alpinia oxyphylla Miq
(Yizhiren in Chinese, YZR) as medication administration groups. Among the three
Chinese herbal medicines, SZR and YZR have been included in the list of
medicinal and edible herbs. The dried seeds of Zizyphus jujuba Mill.var spinosa
(Bunge) Hu ex H.F.Chou (SZR) has been reported to possess soothing effects to
the nerves, as well as liver protecting, anti-oxidation and other effects [10],
which can be used to treat neurasthenia, palpitation and emotional or mental
disorders and other psychiatric diseases [11]. The dried ripe fruit of Alpinia
oxyphylla Miq. (YZR) has been reported to protect nerves, improve learning and
memory ability, and possess anti-oxidation, anti-aging, cardiac protecting and
anti-stress effects [12,13], which is also a homolog of the medicinal and
edible herbs commonly used in the clinical prevention and treatment of
Alzheimer's disease [14]. The dried root of Polygala tenuifolia Willd. or P.
sibirica L. (YZ) has been shown to possess soothing effect, anti-inflammation,
anti-dementia, brain protection, antidepressant, anti-myocardial ischemia, and
other pharmacological effects [15,16]. Folic acid (YS) is a water-soluble vitamin
and is involved in many important reactions and the synthesis of critical
metabolites in the body. Folic acid deficiency in human can lead to an increase
in the incidence of fetal congenital heart and neural tube abnormalities [17],
and similarly, folic acid deficiency in zebrafish can lead to embryos body axis
abnormalities and axoplasmic developmental disorders [18]. Therefore, using
folic acid as a positive control group of the growth and development of
zebrafish in this study is suitable and informative. In addition, after
inoculation and in vitro fertilization, the zebrafish can successfully produce
hundreds of embryos. The in vitro embryo development at 1 day is equivalent to
a 3-month embryonic development in human [19], and the embryos and larvae are
optically transparent [20]. These advantages provide an outstanding theoretical
basis and greatly improve the accuracy of observation upon in vitro and in vivo
treatment [22].
4. Materials and Methods
4.1.
Animal Experiment Ethics Statement
All
animal studies were ethically reviewed and approved by the Committee of the
Ethics on Animal Care and Experiments at The Research Center of Yunnan
University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, and all the animal experiments were
carried out in accordance with the approved guidelines.
4.2.
Experimental Animals
Wild
AB-type zebrafish and Paramecium were purchased from the Chinese Academy of
Sciences Institute of Aquatic Life. Brine shrimp eggs were purchased from a
local company (Aijia Pet Aquarium Supplies Co., Ltd.). The daily breeding of
zebrafish is carried out in a type I 5-layer double-row breeding facility
(purchased from Beijing Aisheng Technology Co., Ltd.). Zebrafish breeding and
culture followed the Westerfield method [21] and brine shrimp culture followed
the breeder’s manual.
4.3.
Reagents and Preparation
Preparation
of embryo culture medium followed an established method (22), which was
composed of 0.127 M NaCl, 5.4 mM KCl, 0.25 mM Na2HPO4, 0.44 mM KH2PO4, 1.3 mM
CaCl2, 1.0 mM MgSO4 and 4.2 mM NaHCO3 at pH 7.2. The extracts of Polygala
tenuifolia, Ziziphus jujuba, and Alpinia oxyphylla were provided by Yunnan
BaiYao Group Chemical Laboratory, with good water solubility after filtration,
and the stock solution (10 mg/mL) was stored at 4ºC. Folic acid (YS) (1 mg/mL)
was purchased from China New Chemical Reagent Research Institute, Shanghai, and
stored at 4ºC in dark. Tricaine, used as an anesthetic, was purchased from
Tianjin Wind Boat Chemical Reagent Technology Co., Ltd., and prepared in
distilled water to 1 mg/mL and stored at 4ºC [23].
4.4.
Larvae Culture
Fertilized
eggs were harvested and washed with pure water for 3 times. Then the fertilized
eggs were transferred into the embryo culture medium and cultured in the
BPH-9082 incubator. Well-developed larvae on day 4 were randomly divided into
groups I and II, and each group was repeated 3 times. Each group was incubated
in a 5 L glass beaker, equipped with a heating rod, thermometer and bubbling oxygen
pump, with 24 h uninterrupted heating and oxygenation, to ensure the water
temperature was between 26.5ºC - 28.5ºC and sufficient oxygen during the
incubation period. The food was provided daily at 9:00 and 18:00 ad libitum.
Group I was fed with Paramecium (density of ≥ 1000 per mL) and group II was fed
with dried brine shrimp powder. The feeding and growth status of larvae in each
beaker were observed daily, and the number of deaths was recorded. The
mortality rate was compared using the chi-squared test. The body length (mm) of
larvae was photographed and calculated using an Olympus-SZX16 inverted
stereomicroscope at 0 d, 5 d, 10 d, and 15 d. The Specific Growth Rate (SGR)
was calculated using the following formula: SGR = 100 (ln(Lt)-ln(L0)) / t, where
L0 and Lt are the average body length (mm) of larvae at the beginning of the
experiment (5 days of age) and at the end (20 days old), t is the number of
days [5].
4.5.
Preparation of Extracts
Polygala
tenuifolia (YZ), Ziziphus jujuba (SZR) and Alpinia oxyphylla (YZR), 1 kg each,
were extracted with 10 volumes of 70% ethanol 3 times for 1 h each extraction.
The extracts were combined and concentrated to 1-2 L (to ensure no ethanol was
left in the concentrate). The extracts were extracted with petroleum ether,
ethyl acetate, and n-butanol, respectively. The extract was dried to obtain
petroleum ether, ethyl acetate, and n-butanol fractions, and the remaining
concentrate was dried to obtain the water extract. The extraction was carried
out in the Chemical Research Department of Yunnan Baiyao Group, and YZ, SZR,
and YZR water extracts were measured to be 112.38 g, 85.0 g, and 105.0 g,
respectively.
4.6. Herb Treatment Administration
Based
on the preliminary results, 100 of the normally developed follicle eggs were
randomly divided into 5 groups, each repeated 3 times. The eggs were placed in
one of the following media: 1) embryonic culture medium (Negative control), 2)
0.10 mg/mL folic acid (Positive control), 3) 0.10 mg/mL YZ, 4) 0.2 mg/mL SZR,
and 5) 0.17 mg/mL YZR, and cultured at 28ºC. The embryos were anesthetized with
1 mg/mL tricaine and placed under an inverted microscope to observe the nerve
plate, neural tube and brain formation time and embryonic development and to
determine whether the treatment(s) promoted the development of the central
nervous system. Statistical analysis. All data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA
and Tukey method using Excel and SPSS17.0 software (p<0.05). The
experimental data were presented as mean ± standard error (mean ± SE).
5. Results
5.1.
Effects of Food on Larvae Growth
As
shown in Table 1, the mortality of group II was significantly worse than that
of group I (p<0.05). The growth rate of body length was significantly higher
in group II comparing to that of group I (Figure 1). On day 15, the SGR was
3.20% in group I and 7.25% in group II, and better average body length and
survival rate were also observed in group II (Table 2).
5.2.
Effect of Herb Treatment on the Formation Time of Nervous System in the
Larvae
After
herb treatment, the formation times of the nerve plate, nerve tube, and brain
were shortest in Positive control group, followed by YZR, Negative control
group, SZR, with the YZ being the longest, which were significantly different
from YS (p<0.05, p<0.01 and p<0.01, respectively) (Table 3-5; Figure:
2-4).
6. Discussion
Polygala
tenuifolia Willd. (YZ), Semen Ziziphi spinosae (SZR) and Alpinia oxyphylla Miq
(YZR) have been widely used as herbal medicines in China for thousands of
years. It was reported that the main component saponins isolated from YZ or SZR
were found to have antipsychotic effects. In addition, pharmacological
investigations have shown that the tepenes, diphenylheptanes and flavones were
the main components in YRZ extract, which were found to have anti-inflammatory,
anti-allergy and neuroprotective activities. The choice of food is an important
factor for the survival rate of zebrafish larvae. In the first 4 days of the
development of the eggs, the hatched larvae receive nutritional support by
absorbing the yolk sac [24]. Starting on the 5th day of development, most of
the larvae begin to move and consume exogenous food. In addition to providing
the necessary nutrients for the growth of larvae, a good food source shall be
easy to prepare, store and clean up. Paramecium, as a common laboratory food
for zebrafish larvae, is small in size and can scatter evenly, so that it can
be easily consumed by the larvae. However, the cultivation of Paramecium, the
replacement of culture medium, and passage can be costly in terms of time and
effort, in practice, because Paramecium must be fed to larvae at a certain
density. Based on previous experience, we found that, compared to Paramecium,
dried brine shrimp powder not only greatly reduced the cost of production and
storage but also performed well in feeding the larvae. Dried brine shrimp
powder 1) can be easily processed to the required particle size for feeding the
larvae, 2) has its own natural pigment, which helps to easily deduce the amount
of food added and the amount of food consumed by the larvae. Residual food can
be easily spotted and removed, which helps to reduce the pollution of water. In
this study, we have also shown that the growth rate and survival rate of larvae
fed with dried brine shrimp powder were significantly better than those of
Paramecium. Therefore, dried brine shrimp powder can be a preferred food source
for zebrafish larvae cultivation [25].
In the
experiment of feeding the larvae, we only select the survival rate and the
growth rate as a survey indicator under the consideration that larvae
individuals are small and difficult to measure weight, so we didn’t consider
the weight gain rate that Shen Zhongming selected (4). The deficiency of our
experiment is that the sedimentation rate, water resistance and decay time of
two kinds of baits had not been measured and compared. In the water, fish
excrement, bait and animal corpses and other organic decomposition of nitrogen
will produce ammonia nitrogen decomposition. And non-ionic form of ammonia
because of the absence of charge so that it can penetrate the cell membrane and
show a toxic effect by the strong fat-soluble [26]. Zhou, et al. (27) used
ammonia chloride to simulate ammonia nitrogen for toxicity test, and found the
LC50 of ammonia nitrogen for 96h was 86.36mg / L, while Han Liqiang, et al.
(28) found LC50 of 24,48,72,96h are 126, 114, 105, 101 mg /ml respectively.
Therefore, when the laboratory decides to change the long-term bait with the
input cost, the above indexes should be taken into account. In addition, in the
choice of experimental fish of different diets, some researchers not only
consider growth index like the visceral weight ratio and the relative fatness,
but also consider physiological index such as the hemoglobin content, plasma
Superoxide Dismutase (SOD) and erythrocyte SOD and so on, so we suggest that
some indicators should be selected according to the needs of experiments during
the process of young fish breeding.
Figure 1:
Larvae body length (day 0-15).
Figure 2:
Effects of herb treatment on the formation of zebrafish neural plate.
Figure 3: Effects
of herb treatment on the formation of zebrafish neural tube.
Figure 4:
Effects of herb treatment on the formation of zebrafish brain.
Group |
Day 0-5 |
Day 6-10 |
Day 10-15 |
I |
31.11 |
16.67 |
5.55 |
II |
12.22* |
6.67* |
1.11* |
*p<0.05 comparing to Group I |
Table 1: Death rate (%) of zebrafish larvae at different development stages.
Group |
Average body length /(mm) |
Survival rate (%) |
I |
4.80±0.03 |
35.56 |
II |
5.34±0.02* |
80.00* |
*p<0.05 comparing to Group I |
Table 2: Survival rate and average body length of two groups after 15 d.
Group |
Formation time (h) |
Negative control |
10.01±0.03* |
YZ |
10.10±0.07* |
SZR |
10.09±0.04* |
YZR |
9.97±0.04* |
YS (Positive control) |
9.87±0.07 |
*p<0.01 comparing to YS (Positive control) |
Table 3: Zebrafish neural plate formation time.
Group |
Formation time (h) |
Negative control |
21.00±0.04* |
YZ |
21.25±0.06* |
SZR |
21.16±0.02* |
YZR |
20.93±0.06* |
YS (Positive control) |
20.83±0.02 |
*p<0.01 comparing to YS (Positive control) |
Table 4: Zebrafish neural tube formation time.
Group |
Formation time (h) |
Negative control |
24.16±0.02* |
YZ |
24.50±0.02* |
SZR |
24.41±0.01* |
YZR |
24.05±0.02* |
YS (Positive control) |
20.83±0.02 |
*p<0.01 comparing to YS (Positive control) |
Table 5: Zebrafish brain formation time.
- Szabo M, Svensson Akusjarvi S, Saxena A,
Liu J, Chandrasekar G, et al. (2017) Cell and small animal models for
phenotypic drug discovery. Drug design, development and therapy 11: 1957-1967.
- Hogan BM, Schulte-Merker S (2017) How to
Plumb a Pisces: Understanding Vascular Development and Disease Using Zebrafish
Embryos. Developmental cell 42: 567-583.
- Allen JR, Bhattacharyya KD, Asante E,
Almadi B, Schafer K, et al. (2017) Role of branchiomotor neurons in controlling
food intake of zebrafish larvae. Journal of neurogenetics 31: 128-137.
- Samaee SM, Nikkhah H, Varga ZM, Rezaei B
(2017) A Simple and Inexpensive Microinjection System for Zebrafish Embryos and
Larvae. Zebrafish 14: 581-585.
- Hensley MR, Leung YF (2010) A convenient
dry feed for raising zebrafish larvae. Zebrafish 7: 219-231.
- Muto A, Kawakami K (2013) Prey capture
in zebrafish larvae serves as a model to study 257 cognitive functions. Frontiers
in neural circuits 7: 110.
- Batel A, Linti F, Scherer M, Erdinger L,
Braunbeck T (2016) Transfer of benzo[a]pyrene from microplastics to Artemia
nauplii and further to zebrafish via a trophic food web experiment: CYP1A
induction and visual tracking of persistent organic pollutants. Environmental
toxicology and chemistry 35: 1656-1666.
- Lawrence C, Best J, Cockington J, Henry
EC, Hurley S, et al. (2016) The Complete and Updated "Rotifer Polyculture
Method" for Rearing First Feeding Zebrafish. Journal of visualized
experiments JoVE: e53629.
- Zha LH, He LS, Lian FM, Zhen Z, Ji HY,
et al. (2015) Clinical Strategy for Optimal Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM)
Herbal Dose Selection in Disease Therapeutics: Expert Consensus on Classic TCM
Herbal Formula Dose Conversion. The American journal of Chinese medicine 43:
1515-1524.
- Chen JY (1973) Chinese health foods and herb
tonics. Am J Chin Med (Gard City N Y) 1: 225-247.
- Qian M, Wu L, Zhang H, Xu M, Li R, et al.
(2012) Determination of 16 insect growth regulators in edible Chinese
traditional herbs by liquid chromatography electrospray tandem mass
spectrometry. Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry 402: 2451-2462
- He ZH, Ge W, Yue GG, Lau CB, He MF, et al.
(2010) Anti-angiogenic effects of the fruit of Alpinia oxyphylla. Journal of ethnopharmacology
132: 443-449.
- Li G, Zhang Z, Quan Q, Jiang R, Szeto SS, et
al. (2016) Discovery, Synthesis, and Functional Characterization of a Novel
Neuroprotective Natural Product from the Fruit of Alpinia oxyphylla for use in
Parkinson's Disease Through LC/MS-Based Multivariate Data Analysis-Guided
Fractionation. Journal of proteome research 15: 2595-2606.
- Lu C, Zhang HY, Ji J, Wang GX (2012) In vivo
anthelmintic activity of Dryopteris crassirhizoma, Kochia scoparia, and
Polygala tenuifolia against Dactylogyrus intermedius (Monogenea) in goldfish
(Carassius auratus). Parasitology research 110: 1085-1090.
- Rodriguez Villanueva J, Rodriguez Villanueva
L (2017) Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology of Ziziphus jujuba Mills.
Phytotherapy research: PTR 31: 347-365.
- Chen J, Yan AL, Lam KY, Lam CT, Li N, et al.
(2014) A chemically standardized extract of Ziziphus jujuba fruit (Jujube)
stimulates expressions of neurotrophic factors and anti-oxidant enzymes in
cultured astrocytes. Phytotherapy research: PTR 28: 1727-1730.
- Ghanbari Niaki A, Mohammadi Joojadeh F, Zare
Kookandeh N, Najafi S, Chaichi MJ, et al. (2013) Liver and plasma nesfatin-1
responses to 6 weeks of treadmill running with or without zizyphus jujuba
liquid extract in female rat. International journal of endocrinology and
metabolism 11: 95-101.
- Chang YM, Chang HH, Tsai CC, Lin HJ, Ho TJ,
et al. (2017) Alpinia oxyphylla Miq. fruit extract activates IGFR-PI3K/Akt
signaling to induce Schwann cell proliferation and sciatic nerve regeneration.
BMC complementary and alternative medicine 17: 184.
- Ju DT, Liao HE, Shibu MA, Ho TJ, Padma VV,
et al. (2015) Nerve Regeneration Potential of Protocatechuic Acid in RSC96
Schwann Cells by Induction of Cellular Proliferation and Migration through
IGF-IR-PI3K-Akt Signaling. The Chinese journal of physiology 58: 412-419.
- Liu A, Zhao X, Li H, Liu Z, Liu B, Mao X, et
al. (2014) 5-Hydroxymethylfurfural, an antioxidant agent from Alpinia oxyphylla
Miq. improves cognitive impairment in Abeta 1-42 mouse model of Alzheimer's
disease. International immunopharmacology 23: 719-725.
- Hong F, Wang L, Wu SL, Tang HC, Wai MS, et
al. (2016) A Review of Three Commonly Used Herbs Which Enhance Memory and New
Evidences Which Show Their Combination Could Improve Memory in Young Animals.
Mini reviews in medicinal chemistry 17: 1537-1547.
- Park JH, Kim JS, Jang DS, Lee SM (2006) Effect of Polygala tenuifolia root extract on cerebral ischemia and reperfusion. The American journal of Chinese medicine 34: 115-123.
- Sur B, Lee B, Yoon YS, Lim P, Hong R, et al.
(2017) Extract of Polygala tenuifolia Alleviates Stress-Exacerbated Atopy-Like
Skin Dermatitis through the Modulation of Protein Kinase A and p38
Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase Signaling Pathway. International journal of
molecular sciences 18: 190.
- Muralidharan P, Sarmah S, Marrs JA (2015)
Zebrafish retinal defects induced by ethanol exposure are rescued by retinoic
acid and folic acid supplement. Alcohol 49: 149-163.
- Yue C, Ji C, Zhang H, Zhang LW, Tong J, et
al. (2017) Protective effects of folic acid on PM2.5-induced cardiac
developmental toxicity in zebrafish embryos by targeting AhR and
Wnt/beta-catenin signal pathways. Environmental toxicology 32: 2316-2322.
- Goolish EM, Okutake K, Lesure S (1999) Growth and survivorship of larval zebrafish Danio rerio on processed diets. North American Journal of Aquaculture 61: 189-198.