Which to Choose? Surgery or Upper GI Endoscopy in Symptomatic Gallstones
Ashfaq Chandio1*, Syed Altaf Naqvi1, Shariq Sabri1, Fuad Aftab2, Mujeeb Abassi3, Zainab Shaikh3, Khanzadi Chandio4, Farheen Soomro4, Aijaz Memon4
1Tameside NHS Foundation
Trust Hospital, UK
2Mallow General
Hospital, Co. Cork, Ireland Republic
3Liaquat University of Medical & Health Sciences,
Jamshoro, Pakistan
4Shaheed Mohtarama Benazir Bhutto Medical University & Chandka Medical College Larkana, Pakistan
*Corresponding author: Ashfaq Chandio, Tameside NHS Foundation Trust Hospital, UK. Email: chandioashfaq@yahoo.com
Received Date: 04 January, 2019; Accepted Date: 21 January, 2019; Published Date: 29 January, 2019
Citation: Chandio A, Naqvi SA, Sabri S, Aftab F, Abassi M, et al. (2019) Which to choose? Surgery or Upper GI Endoscopy in Symptomatic Gallstones. J Anesth Surg Rep: JASR-112. DOI: 10.29011/ JASR-112. 100012
Background:
Gallstones are common;
they do not cause any symptoms in many people. About one in three people with
gallstones develop symptoms (symptomatic). There are wide range of
gastrointestinal symptoms have been linked to gallstones but causal
relationship has not been established yet. It has always been a challenge to
differentiate between upper gastrointestinal symptoms due to gall stones or any
other causes. There is conflicting evidence that preoperative Gastroscopy is
useful in identifying medically treatable diseases in patients undergoing
Cholecystectomy.
Aim: To evaluate significance of Upper GI
endoscopy as a pre-operative investigative tool in symptomatic gallstones.
Methods: Prospective observational multicentre study of 433
patients undergoing Laparoscopic cholecystectomy from December 2014 to November
2016. All patients diagnosed with gallstones based on ultrasound abdomen,
irrespective of age and sex.
All patients were subjected to Upper
Gastrointestinal Endoscopy 24 to 48
hours before cholecystectomy biopsy were obtained for histopathology if required. Patients decline
surgery, Pregnant ladies, CBD stone, obstructive jaundice, carcinoma of gall
bladder, were excluded.
Results: During this period, 433
patients. The female to male ratio 3.5:1 (337 versus 96), and the mean patient
age was 45.10 ± 6.31 years (21 to 65 years). 266 (61.78%) Patients were present
with atypical pain and 167 (38.21%) typical pain. Ultrasound revealed multiple
stones 335(77.36%), single stone 98 (22.63%), impacted stone at the neck of
gallbladder was found in 76 (17.55%) patients, Thick wall gallbladder was seen
in 247 (57.04%) patients and contracted gallbladder 51 (11.77%) patients. Pre-operative
upper gastrointestinal endoscopy findings revealed gastritis in 108 (24.94%),
gastric ulcer 55 (12.70%), duodenal ulcer in 44 (10.16%), GERD in 31 (7.15%), Esophagitis
in 37 (8.54%) cases, polyps 21(4.84%) and carcinoma of stomach 9 (2.07%). In
all patients with typical pain complete relief of symptoms were observed within
13 days post- operatively. Out of 266 (61.43%) cases with atypical pain had
persistence of symptoms in 157 (59.02%) cases up to four months.
Conclusion: We recommend that upper gastrointestinal endoscopy should be
performed preoperatively in
patients with nonspecific upper abdominal pain and history of peptic ulcer
disease.
Keywords: Cholecystectomy;
Cholelithiasis; Gastroscopy
1. Methods
Prospective observational
multicentre study involving Tameside NHS Foundation Trust Hospital UK, Mallow
General Hospital, Cork, Ireland Republic, Liaquat University of Medical &
Health Sciences, Jamshoro Pakistan, Shaheed Mohtarama Benazir Bhutto Medical
University & Chandka Medical College Larkana, Pakistan. From December 2014
to November 2016. All patients diagnosed with gallstones based on ultrasound
abdomen and typical or atypical abdominal pain, irrespective of age and sex.
All patients were subjected to Upper Gastrointestinal Endoscopy 24
to 48 hours before cholecystectomy biopsy were obtained for
histopathology if required. The OGD examinations were performed by
Gastroenterologists and GI surgeons. Where polyps were found, they were removed
and assessed histopathologically. Scheduled cholecystectomy was postponed for
three months when there were gastric or duodenal ulcers, gastric polyps, or
inflammatory changes of gastric mucous membrane until histopathologic results
were obtained and ulcers healed. The decision for cholecystectomy was made by
the surgeons. The following preoperative parameters were recorded: age, sex,
obesity, previous abdominal surgery, presentation with acute
cholecystitis, pancreatitis or obstructive jaundice, ultrasonography detection
of gallbladder wall thickening or gallbladder stones, and the presence of
Common Bile Duct (CBD) stones. Clinical patterns of patient’s pain, endoscopic
and pathologic findings as well as related comorbidities were obtained from the
patient’s case notes. Endoscopic findings divided the problem into four main
groups, normal, inflammation, ulcer, and others (polyps, varices etc.) whilst the
pathological findings were defined as benign and malignant. Inclusion criteria:
Symptomatic patients willing to participate in the study, ultrasound proven
gallstones. Exclusion criteria: Those patients not keen, unfit for
surgery, Pregnant ladies due to risk of foetal loss, CBD stone, obstructive
jaundice, carcinoma of gall bladder, were excluded.
2. Statistical Analysis
Data were
analysed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS, version 17).
Mean values were compared using the Student t test. Univariate
analysis of categorical variables was performed by the chi-square test.
3. Results
During this
period, 433 patients. The female to male ratio 3.5:1 (337 versus 96), and the
mean patient age was 45.10 ± 6.31 years (21 to
65 years) (Table 1, Figure 1). 266 (61.78%) atypical pain and 167
(38.21%) Patients were present with typical pain (Figure 2). Ultrasound
revealed multiple stones 335(77.36%), single stone 98 (22.63%), impacted stone
at the neck of gallbladder was found in 76 (17.55%) patients, Thick wall
gallbladder was seen in 247 (57.04%) patients and contracted gallbladder 51
(11.77%) patients (Table 2, Figure 3). Pre-operative upper
gastrointestinal endoscopy findings revealed gastritis in 108 (24.94%), gastric
ulcer 55 (12.70%), duodenal ulcer in 44 (10.16%), GERD in 31 (7.15%),
Esophagitis in 37 (8.54%) cases, polyps 21(4.84%) and carcinoma of stomach 9
(2.07%). (Table 3, Figure 4). In all patients with typical pain complete
relief of symptoms were observed within 13 days post- operatively, out of
266(61.43%) cases with atypical pain had persistence of symptoms in 157
(59.02%) cases up to four months (Table 4)
4. Discussion
Gallstone
disease remains one of the most common medical problems leading to surgical
intervention. 70 - 85% per cent of people with cholelithiasis are
asymptomatic [7] or have nonspecific symptoms such as pain in their
abdomen, stomach, back or shoulder, which may be misattributed to other
conditions such as dyspepsia or general back ache. In most cases, asymptomatic
gallstone is detected incidentally through imaging such as ultrasound or MRI as
part of investigations for other conditions. For about 20% of people with
cholelithiasis, the condition is symptomatic and can cause morbidity and
complications (cholecystitis, cholangitis, obstructive jaundice, pancreatitis)
that can be extremely painful and, in some cases, life threatening and needing
emergency treatment as well as high costs of medical care. In the
United States, Gallstone disease is the second most expensive digestive disease
only surpassed by gastroesophageal reflux disease. Every year about
700,000 cholecystectomies are performed in the United States [8], and
190,000 patients with gallstone disease undergo surgery in
Germany [9]. About 70,000 cholecystectomies are performed every year
in the UK, with significant costs for the NHS. The health care costs of
gallstone disease (~ 6.5 billion dollars/year) increased by 20% over the last
three decades in the United States [10]. Gallstones found
incidentally in the investigation of gastrointestinal symptoms may become
falsely incriminated to explain pathology that arises outside the biliary
tree [11]. There is variation within the NHS in how asymptomatic
gallbladder stones are managed once they have been diagnosed. Some adults are
offered treatment to prevent symptoms and complications developing.
Others are
offered a watch-and-wait approach, and only have active treatment once the
stones begin to cause symptoms. The differential diagnosis between
symptomatic gallstones and inflammatory disorders of gastrointestinal tract is
difficult due to the similar symptoms. Sosada et al. assayed 2,800 patients who
were treated for symptomatic cholelithiasis. 2,325 of them were female and 475
were male patients in the study about 42 % of the patients had pathological
changes during their esophagogastroduodenoscopy, in 37.18 % an inflammatory
component was found [12]. In another retrospective study by Dimitriou et
al. data of 766 patients was analysed. The patients underwent a preoperative
esophagogastroduodenoscopy independently of their symptoms and they found inflammatory
changes of the upper gastrointestinal tract in 43.1 % of their
patients [13]. Sosada et al. also state that some patients still suffered
from epigastric pain after a successful surgery, which might be due to an
unrecognised inflammatory disease of the upper gastrointestinal tract. The
diagnosis of a peptic ulcer led to a cancellation of the cholecystectomy and
was replaced by PPI therapy because of the high risk for bleedings or
perforation. Only after medical treatment some patients still underwent a
cholecystectomy due to persisting epigastric pain. In helicobacter pylori
-positive patients an additional treatment with antibiotics was
necessary [12]. The study of Dimitriou et al. however did not
show any significantly higher necessity to change a surgical treatment to a
medical therapy in patients with atypical epigastric pain [13]. There
are wide range of gastrointestinal symptoms have been linked to
gallstones but causal relationship has not been established
yet [1,3]. It is commonly accepted that removal of the gallbladder is the
best treatment for symptomatic gallstone disease [14]. However, less focus
has been on patient selection and typical or common symptoms of this disease to
understand prevailing symptoms after surgery. Nevertheless, given the high
proportion of non-specific abdominal symptoms in the people with known
gallstones may lead to unjustifiable cholecystectomies [1,15].
There are a
range of endoscopic, surgical and medical treatments available to treat
gallstone disease. Surgery to remove the gallbladder (cholecystectomy) is the
most common way to treat biliary pain or cholecystitis caused by gallstones and
is one of the most commonly performed surgical procedures in the NHS. An
upper GI endoscopy has been recommended in patients with nonspecific upper
abdominal pain, history of peptic ulcer disease and persisting pain after
laparoscopic cholecystectomy [4]. In our study Pre-operative upper
gastrointestinal endoscopy findings revealed normal gastroscopy in 34.03% (130
out of 382 patients) this is in contrast with other studies. Rassek et
al., in his study 589 out of 960 patients underwent gastroscopy for elective
cholecystectomy, however 56% had normal gastroscopy, 11.3% (113 patients)
underwent a change in plan of therapy because of the OGD
findings, [16] and recommended that investigation of the upper
gastrointestinal tract must precede an elective cholecystectomy. Schenk et al.,
in his study, 1064/ 1143 (93.1%) patients underwent OGD and 345 patients
(30.2%) had pathological findings. Of these, 68.3% were inflammatory in nature
28 patients (2.5%) underwent additional GI surgical procedures along with
cholecystectomy and bile duct exploration 19.8% (227 patients) underwent
pharmacological treatment of the gastrointestinal disease after their biliary
surgery [17], and suggested that owing to the high incidence of
concurrent disease in the upper GI tract, preoperative gastroscopy should be
performed prior to elective surgical therapy of symptomatic gallstones. Study
of Thybusch et al. discuss the value and therapeutic implications of routine
OGD before cholecystectomy, in his study 47.3% (160/338) patients undergoing
cholecystectomy also had Upper GI endoscopy, amongst those he observed
gastritis (25.7%), peptic ulcer disease (6.8%), hiatus hernia (4.7%) polyps
(3.2%), oesophagitis (3%), gastric erosions (1.8%) and gastric cancer (.6%).
Findings on
gastroscopy did not necessarily correlate with clinical symptoms. OGD findings
influenced management in 8.3% of patients and the surgery was postponed
awaiting medical treatment. Further, two patients with gastric cancer underwent
gastrectomy [18]. In studies by Faisal et al and Mozafar et
al found 77.2% and 83% of patents with atypical pain had abnormal OGD
findings [19,20]. This establishes the importance of UGE prior to
elective cholecystectomy especially with atypical pain. In our study, the
diagnosis of peptic ulcer did not lead to a cancellation or the postponing of
the cholecystectomy. They were treated simultaneously with PPI and in cases of
helicobacter pylori-positive with triple therapy. The reproducibility of the study would be difficult due to the subjective selection of
the results. In the case of more than one existing option, it was not possible
to select all diagnoses. This could lead to the impression that some diagnoses
are more frequent than others. In the present study, therapeutic
approach was changed in 9 (2.35%) who were diagnosed with malignancy in
pathological reports.
Prospective design
of the study, it was possible to evaluate the symptoms of the participating
patients. A potential weakness of study variation in practice in country
(Asia and Europe), cost effectiveness of routine OGD for every patient. In
author’s opinion, it would have been necessary to exclude patients
with the clear diagnosis of a cholecystitis with ultrasound abdominal. An acute
cholecystitis would almost always require surgical treatment, as it explains
the symptoms. Higher incidence of concurrent upper gastrointestinal
problems in patients with gall stones and atypical abdominal pain OGD before
elective cholecystectomy can highly influence the management which in this
group can be clinically helpful regarding postoperative outcomes. It would also
have been necessary to follow up the patients subsequently
5. Conclusion
We recommend Preoperative Gastroscopy in patients with nonspecific upper abdominal pain and history of peptic ulcer disease
Figure
1
Figure 2:
Figure 3
Figure 4
Demographics |
|||||
Cohort |
Female |
Male |
Ratio |
Mean Age |
Range |
433 |
337 |
96 |
3.5 : 1 |
45.1 Years |
21 – 65 Yrs |
Table 1: Demographics.
Ultrasound Findings |
Cases |
Percentage |
Multiple stones |
335 |
77.36% |
Single |
98 |
22.63% |
Impacted |
76 |
17.55% |
Thick wall |
247 |
57.04% |
Contracted |
51 |
11.77% |
Table 2: Ultrasound.
Condition |
Number |
Percentage |
Gastritis |
108 |
24.94 |
Gastric ulcer |
55 |
12.70 |
Duodenal ulcer |
44 |
10.16 |
GERD |
31 |
7.15 |
Esophagitis |
37 |
8.54 |
Polyps |
21 |
4.84 |
Ca. Stomach |
9 |
2.07 |
Table 3: Pre-Operative OGD.
Presentation |
Cases |
Percentage |
Days |
Typical pain |
167 |
38.21% |
13 |
Atypical pain |
266 |
61.78% |
122 |
- Schirmer BD, Winters KL, Edlich RF (2005) Cholelithiasis and cholecystitis. J Long Term Eff Med Implants 15: 329-338.
- Stinton LM, Shaffer EA (2012) Epidemiology of gallbladder disease: cholelithiasis and cancer. Gut Liver 6: 172-187.
- Kraag N, Thijs C, Knipschild P (1995) Dyspepsia-how noisy are gallstones? A meta-analysis of epidemiologic studies of biliary pain, dyspeptic symptoms, and food intolerance. Scand J Gastroenterol 30: 411-421.
- Fahlke J, Ridwelski K, Manger T, Grote R, Lippert H (2001) Diagnostic workup before laparoscopic cholecystectomy-which diagnostic tools should be used?. Hepato gastroenterol 48: 59-65.
- Ure BM, Troidl H, Spangenberger W, Lefering R, Dietrich A, et al. (1992) Evaluation of routine upper digestive tract endoscopy before laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Br J Surg 79: 1174-1177.
- Al-Azawi D, Rayis A, Hehir DJ (2006) Esophagogastroduodenoscopy prior to laparoscopic cholecystectomy. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A 16: 593-597.
- Sakorafas HG, Milingos D, Peros G (2007) Asymptomatic cholelithiasis: is cholecystectomy really needed? A critical reappraisal 15 years after the introduction of laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Dig Dis Sci 52: 1313-1325.
- No authors listed (1993) National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Conference Statement on gallstones and laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Am J Surg 165: 390-398.
- Lammert F, Neubrand MW, Bittner R, Feussner H, Greiner L, et al. (2007) S3-guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of gallstones. German Society for Digestive and Metabolic Diseases and German Society for Surgery of the Alimentary Tract. Z Gastroenterol 45: 971-1001.
- Everhart JE, Ruhl CE (2009) Burden of digestive diseases in the United States. Part III: liver, biliary tract and pancreas. Gastroenterology 136: 1134-1144.
- Halldestam I, Kullman E, Borch K (2008) Defined indications for elective cholecystectomy for gallstone disease. Br J Surg 95: 620-626.
- Sosada K, Zurawinski W, Piecuch J, Stepien T, Makarska J (2005) Gastroduodenoscopy: a routine examination of 2,800 patients before laparoscopic cholecystectomy. In: Surgical endoscopy 19: 1103-1108.
- Dimitriou, Reckmann B, Nephuth O, Betzler M (2012) Stellenwert der routinemäßigen präoperativen Ösophagogastroduodenoskopie vor elektiver Cholezystektomie. IN. Zentralblatt für Chirurgie, 137: 38- 42.
- Berger MY, Olde Hartman TC, Bohnen AM (2003) Abdominal symptoms: do they disappear after cholecystectomy? Surg Endosc 17: 1723-1728.
- Glambek I, Arnesjo B, Soreide O (1989) Correlation between gallstones and abdominal symptoms in a random population. Results from a screening study. Scand J Gastro‐ enterol 24: 277-281.
- Rassek D, Osswald J, Stock W (1988) Routine gastroscopy before cholecystectomy. Chirurg 59: 335-337.
- Schwenk W, Bohm B, Badke A, Zarras K, Stock W (1992) Preoperative esophagogas- troduodenoscopy before elective surgical therapy of symptomatic cholelithiasis. Leber Magen Darm 22: 225-229.
- Thybusch A, Schaube H, Schweizer E, Gollnick D, Grimm H (1996) Significant value and therapeutic implications of routine gastroscopy before cholecystectomy. J Chir (Paris) 133: 171-174.
- Faisal A, Gadallah AN, Omar SA, Nagy MA (2013) The role of upper Gastrointestinal Endoscopy in Prevention of Post - Cholecystectomy pain prior to the elective surgical therapy of chronic cholecystitis. Med J Cairo Uni 81: 289-293.
- Mozafer M, Sobhiyeh M, Heiba Tollahi M (2010) Is esophagogastroduodenoscopy essential prior to the elective surgical therapy of symptomatic cholelithiasis?. Gastro enteroscopy and Hepatology from bed to Bench 3: 77-82.