Wood Fire Detection by Imitating Beetle Olfaction with Gas Sensors
Sebastian Paczkowski*
Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg, Germany
*Corresponding author: Sebastian Paczkowski, Chair of Forest Operations, Faculty of Environment and Natural Resources, Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg, Germany. Tel: +4915731622127; Fax: +497612033763; Email: Sebastian.Paczkowski@foresteng.uni-freiburg.de
Received Date: 08 February, 2018; Accepted Date: 14 March, 2018; Published Date: 23 March, 2018
Citation: Paczkowski S (2018) Wood Fire Detection by Imitating Beetle Olfaction with Gas Sensors. Curr Trends Entomol: CTEZS-105. DOI: 10.29011/ CTEZS-105. 000005
1. Abstract
Volatile organic compound (VOC) based fire risk assessment systems for wood land fires can shorten the time between the outbreak of a fire and the arrival of fire crews. This can prevent the development of crown fires, which are harder to control than ground fires. Metal-oxide semiconductor gas sensors derive of good technical properties for VOC detection. In this study, the VOC emissions of heated lignocellulose biomass (Eucalyptus globulus) were analyzed by GC-MS. Eucalyptol and furfural showed the highest emission rates. All of the 20 identified VOCs were tested on the antenna of the fire beetle Merimna atrata and eucalyptol and furfural both were among the 13 VOCs that were significantly electrophysiological active on the antenna of the beetle. Three semi-conductor metal oxide gas sensors allowed a monitoring of the temperature dependent VOC pattern. The feasibility of such gas sensors for early fire detection is discussed.
2.
Keywords: Electrophysiology; Eucalyptol; Fire risk assessment; Furfural; Insect olfaction;
Merimna atrata;
Semi-conductor metal oxide gas sensors; VOC; 2-methoxyphenol α-pinene
Eucalyptus species are grown worldwide in plantations and in some countries already dominate the flora [1]. While the seed release of several eucalypt species is induced by heat as a result of an adaption to frequent wood land fires, these fires are a serious threat for the people. An effective fire management includes measures like prescribed burnings, evacuation plans for inhabited areas, well trained fire crews, and automatized early fire warning systems. It is important to detect a fire early, because when the crowns of the trees ignite the fire will extend very fast. Factors affecting the crown fire risk are a large organic fuel load (e.g. dry litter, grass, bushes, smaller trees, and dried bark), a long period of hot and dry weather, and a high differentiation in the tree heights. In some regions of the world the increasing average temperature favors woodland fires. An improved fire risk assessment can decrease the time interval between the start of a ground fire and the arrival of fire crews, which is crucial to reduce the risk of a crown fire [2,3].
The detection of smoke is an established way to locate fires. Smoke detectors are sensitive for optical cues, particle size distributions, or gaseous products of the thermal degradation of lignocellulose [3,4]. A smoldering fire in a eucalypt plantation is already a high risk. Therefore, an assessment of the fire risk by sensors is more feasible. When forest biomass heats up, the volatile accessory compounds (VOCs: Volatile Organic Compounds) of the wood and the leaves are emitted. These VOCs comprise mainly tree species specific monoterpenes. If the heat increases further, the bonds of lignocellulose macromolecules (mainly hemicelluloses, cellulose, and lignin) will be oxidized incompletely at low lambda values (λ<1, reductive or pyrolytic phase) [6-8]. This will release the gases H2, CO, and VOCs. Cellulose and hemicelluloses predominantly yield VOCs from the chemical group of furans [7-13] and lignin predominantly yields methoxyphenols [5,13,15-18]. The order of VOCs emitted before the ignition can be used as a cue for a metal-oxide semiconductor gas sensor system [3,13,19,20] to assess an increasing fire risk. Established VOC sensors, e.g. metal-oxide semiconductor gas sensors [19,20], lack of sensitivity towards single VOCs in a complex VOC pattern. This is due to their operation principle: An electrical signal is generated by means of a resistance alteration of the sensor surface. The alteration is caused by the interaction (ionosorption, reduction and/or oxidation) of a VOC with the band structure of the metal-oxide crystal surface. Therefore, metal-oxide semiconductor sensors are selective for different states of VOC oxygenation rather than for the precise chemical structure of one VOC [20]. Sensor arrays combine different metal-oxide semiconductor sensors to enhance the selectivity by means of a signal pattern analysis [21,22].
The selective detection of VOCs specific for heated eucalypt wood and leaves is necessary to assess an increasing fire risk in eucalypt forests [13]. These VOCs should have three characteristics: 1) they should be emitted before the ignition of eucalypt wood and leaves in order to allow a sensor system to assess the fire risk before ignition; 2) they should occur in prominent quantities to be selectively detectable, because metal-oxide semiconductor sensor systems lack of sensitivity towards single VOCs in a VOC composition; and 3) in eucalypt forests they should be emitted exclusively by heated eucalypt wood and/or leaves to avoid false alarms.
Insects are able to detect VOCs with high accuracy, as they depend on their ecological information. The biochemical mechanism of insect olfaction is based on odorant binding proteins (OBPs) in the sensilla on insect antenna. These proteins bind VOCs selectively. The resulting protein/VOC complex can depolarize neurons by activating ion channels via receptor triggered G-coupled protein cascades. This complex biological mechanism enables insects to detect VOCs with high selectivity and sensitivity [23-25].
M. atrata approaches eucalypt forest stands shortly after the fire as the first colonizer to avoid competition and predators. The beetles mate and oviposition selected eucalypt stems [26]. They use their IR sensitive organs, which are situated on the ventrolateral sides of the abdomen, to detect fires and to avoid landing on hot patches [26-29]. This study investigates the temperature dependent VOC emissions of E. globulus wood and leaves. The olfaction of the fire beetle M. atrata is used to learn from nature`s evolutional adaption to fire detection. The resulting concept is transferred to semi-conductor gas sensors, which are used to detect an increasing fire risk.
2.
Material and Methods
Wood and leave samples of five E. globulus trees were cut into 1mm flakes and 0.5 cm2 pieces, respectively. 2g of each material was used for the experiments with wood and with leaves. For the experiments with both wood and leaves, 1g wood chips and 1g leaves were mixed. A reconstructed GC oven (Fractovap Series 4160, Carlo ErbaStrumentazione, Rodano, Italy) was used to heat the E. globulus samples. Synthetic air (1bar, 20% O2 in N, Alpha Gaz, Düsseldorf, Germany) was led into a glass flask that contained the sample. A rotary vane pump (Thomas Division, Sheboygan, USA) sucked 0.6 L air in 30 s out of the flask through calibrated charcoal filters (1,8 mg Charcoal, CLSA Filter, Daumazan sur Arize, France) to take an empty control sample and samples at 25°C, 50°C, 75°C, 100°C, 150°C, 200°C, 250°C, and 300°C.
2.2. VOC Analysis and Quantification
The charcoal filters were washed with 75 μl dichloromethane/methanol (2:1). 1µl of the eluate was analyzed by a GC-MS system (6890N
Network GC System, 30 m × 0.25 mm HP-5 MS, 95% Dimethyl- 5%
Diphenyl-Polysiloxane, nonpolar column with 0.25-μm
film thickness / 5973 quadrupole mass spectrometer, Agilent Technologies, Santa
Clara, USA). The following oven program and detector parameters were applied:
initial temperature: 40°C for 2.5
min, rate 1: 6, 2°C per min to 250°C, final hold: 10 min, MS in scan mode (m/z
detection range of 20-354 per 0.5 s). The VOCs were analyzed with the Enhanced
Chemstation Version D00.00.38 software (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara,
USA), the Mass Spectral Search Library of the National Institute of Standards
and Technology NIST (Gaithersburg, USA), and the MS Interpreter Version 0.9f
(Gaithersburg, USA). The identity of VOCs was further confirmed by calculating
the linear retention index (C7 to C24 straight-chain hydrocarbons [30]) by using purchased standard VOCs at 10-4 dilution (Table 1).
The area of the most abundant ion in the purchased standard VOC MS-spectra was
used for quantification. The emission rate was calculated in ng/L×60s. This raw
data was analyzed for normal distribution by the Shapiro-Wilk test, and, as
most data sets were not normally distributed, displayed in box plots showing
the median, upper/lower quartile, minimum, and maximum of the respective
emission rates. Table 1 shows the identified
VOCs of E.
globulus leaves, wood or wood and
leaves in the order of their retention index within the respective chemical
group on a nonpolar HP-5 column.
2.3. Insects and EAG
In summer 2009 and 2010, adult Merimna atrata were collected one to ten days after a fire on stems of charred eucalypt trees in the Dwelling up State Forest, Western Australia, in the Mundaring State Forest, Western Australia, and in summer 2010 and 2011 in the region of Jurien Bay, Western Australia. They were kept on 10% saccharose sugar water and water diet at 25 ± 1°C / 40% rel. hum. and a 12/12 day/night period. Before performing the electro-antennogram serial dilutions of the VOCs (EAG), the electroantennographic (EAD) detection was performed (data not shown, method described in [13]) in order to select electrophysiological active VOCs. These VOCs (Table 1) were diluted with paraffin oil (Uvasol quality, Merck/VWR, Darmstadt, Germany) at different concentrations (10-7 to 10-2 g/g). App. 200µL of the mixtures were dropped on 2-cm2 filter papers and put into a 10-ml glass syringe. 2.5 ml of the airspace in the syringe was led into a stream of humidified air (500 ml / min, 23°C, 80% rel. hum.) and directed to the excised antenna of the beetles. The signal output was mV × 100 (amplification factor). The procedure was repeated three times per dilution step and beetle (n=3) and on five animals (n=5 for the species). For more technical details on the EAG setup, see [31]. According to the results of the Shapiro-Wilks test for normal distribution, the T-test for paired samples or the Mann-Whitney U-test was applied to test for significant differences between mixture and paraffin oil controls.
2.4. Gas Sensors
Three gas sensors GGS5330 WO2, GGS2330 SnO2, and GGS1330 SnO2 (UST-Umweltsensortechnik, Geschwenda, Germany) were operated at 200 Ω, 200 Ω, and 75 Ω, respectively, and at 5 V. The VOCs emitted during thermal oxidation experiments of E. globulus wood, leaves and wood and leaves with temperatures from 25°C to 240°C were led through a sensor chamber and the resistance of the sensors was measured in intervals of 1s. The sensors where calibrated on eucalyptol and furfural and during the thermal oxidation samples VOC samples were taken at 25°C, 150°C, 200°C, and 240°C and analyzed as described above. The same setup was used as for the VOC sampling, but instead of the glass cylinder, a stainless-steel cylinder with lower heat conduction was used. This decelerated the heating of the biomass and simulated the pre-ignition situation. The biomass was not burned but showed a dark brown color after the sensor experiments.
3. Results and Discussion
Nine terpenes, five furans, five methoxyphenols, and one benzene compound were identified and quantified in the VOC analysis. The vapor pressures of the compounds corresponded to the order of their linear retention indices (Table 1). Camphor was the only exception (Table 1). The VOC emission pattern showed clear qualitative and quantitative trends (Figure 1).
In all three tissues the ignition took place in the heating phase from 250°C to 300°C. This is in accordance with the auto-ignition temperature of solid wood at low heat fluxes without direct exposure to a flame [32]. The VOC emission rates in the samples taken at 300°C were low, as only ashes and residual VOCs had remained in the glass flask at this temperature. The terpenes were mainly emitted by the leaves, while wood contained low amounts of α-pinene and eucalyptol, as well. The furans and the methoxyphenols were mainly emitted by the wood as products of the thermal degradation of hemicellulose/cellulose and lignin, respectively [13]. Furans and methoxyphenols were also emitted by the leave tissue, as the leaves contained low amounts of lignocellulose, as well. In all three tissues the terpenes were already emitted at low temperature. Their emission rate was correlated to the temperature (Clausius Clapeyron equation) and to the concentration in the tissue (Henrie’s law or Raoult’s law). Within the group of terpenes, the bicyclic monoterpenes α-pinene and eucalyptol had the highest emission rates in all three tissues (Figure 1). At the temperature stages between 25°C to 150°C both VOCs constituted 87-96% (standard deviation 3-10%) of the total emission from the wood and leaves samples. The relative amount of eucalyptol and α-pinene in the total emissions decreased from 70% (12% standard deviation) at 200°C to 26% (5% standard deviation) at 250°C and 11% (12% standard deviation) at 300°C. Eucalyptol is the only VOC that was emitted throughout the heating process in the wood and leaves samples with an emission maximum between 150°C and 250°C (Figure 1).
Limonene, β-pinene, epiglobulol, and aromadendrene were emitted by the leaves (Figure 1) with a comparable temperature related dynamic as eucalyptol and α-pinen. The terpenes camphor, β-myrcen, and camphene did not show this dynamic. It is possible that camphene had formed due to oxidation of α-pinene at high temperature, as it is suggested by Neuenschwander et al. [33]. This would explain its exclusive presence at 200°C and 250°C in the leave and in the wood and leaves samples. Camphor occurs at very low emission rates in the leaves samples at 300°C which suggests that it is an oxidation product of camphene, which was the only structurally related terpene present at this temperature (Figure 1).
In the wood, leave and in the wood and leaves samples the thermal degradation started of hemicellulose, and/or cellulose started at 150°C. At 200°C all leaves samples emitted furfural at emission rates between 9 and 42 ng/L×60s (7% total emission, 3% standard deviation). All wood and leaves samples emitted furfural at emission rates between 49 and 81 ng/L×60s (15% total emission, 8% standard deviation). The wood samples showed furfural emission rates in the range of 4 to 129 ng/L×60s (73% total emission, 10% standard deviation)
The furfural emission of all wood and leaves samples increased further to 250°C (50% total emission, 8% standard deviation) and decreased to 300°C (11% total emission, 5% standard deviation). At 250°C the sample 2 of the wood and leaves samples showed the highest emission of a single VOC in the whole emission pattern of the wood and leaves samples (810 ng/L×60s, 68%, and the group of furans had the highest total emission among the four chemical groups. All wood and leaves samples emitted lower amounts of secondary products of furfural (2-furanmethanol, 5-methylfurfural, and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural). All three tissues emitted methoxyphenols at 250°C and 300°C. The emissions of methoxyphenols from the wood and leaves samples were lower than the emission of terpenes and furans and took place exclusively at 250°C and 300°C. Within this group, 2-methoxyphenol showed the highest emission followed by 2-methoxy-4-formylphenol. 1% (0.3% standard deviation) of the total emission at 250°C and 12% (8% standard deviation) at 300°C were 2-methoxyphenol and 2-methoxy-4-formylphenol.
The antenna of M. atrata responded
to most of the terpenes. The intensity of the reaction in mV is correlated to
the vapor pressure of the terpene. A higher vapor pressure leads to a stronger
reaction. Terpene emissions are not relevant for fire detection, as the risk of
false alarm scenarios for the beetle is very high. In a forest ecosystem there
are many sources of terpenes, e.g. trees under drought stress, physically
damaged conifers, and flowers. The antennae responded significantly to furfural
and 2-furanmethanol at a dilution of 10-4 (Figure 2 and 3). Other furans do not elicit an
electrophysiological response, as they have a lower vapor pressure (Table 1). Furans indicate the start of the
degradation of wood, which can be a cue for the beetle. The VOC with the best
relation of vapor pressure (0.179, Table 1) and
detection limit (10-4, Figure 2 and 3) is 2-methoxyphenol. This VOC is the
most sensitive detected in this study, as its vapor pressure is low, and the
detection limit is low, as well. The ecological importance of 2-methoxyphenol
is also suggested by another study on a related fire beetle species [34]. The beetle is able to sense furans and
2-methoxyphenol, which enables it to detect smoke plumes and lignocelluloses at
high temperatures.
Figure 4 shows the temperature dependent response of three selected semi-conductor metal oxide gas sensors to the VOCs emitted during the thermal treatment of E. globulus biomass.
As furan emissions are tree species unspecific, a sensor system detecting furfural could assess the fire risk of any lignocellulose biomass. Sources of false alarm can be microbial or auto-oxidative degradation of dead wood and dry litter, fungal infection of dead wood or cooked meat [35]. However, the kinetics of thermally induced oxidative depolymerization is faster than auto-oxidative or enzymatic processes. Therefore, the emission rate of furfural or furans from other sources is low. Furfural is not emitted by decaying vertebrates [36,37].
The onset of a fire is not necessarily gradual, but can be spontaneously, e.g. caused by hot exhaust fumes of motorbikes or burning cigarettes. A fire risk assessment before the ignition is not possible in such cases. Another restriction of the proposed sensor system is the uneven and unpredictable spatial distribution of odor plumes. This could result in a dense network of sensors or in a concentration of a few sensors at hot spots, e.g. for the protection of households. A sensor system in eucalypt plantations or forests can include methoxyphenol detection to further increase its operating spectrum from fire risk assessment by furan emission to smoke detection. As methoxyphenols are, like furans, species unspecific, this feature can be applied for any lignocellulose biomass.
4. Conclusion and Outlook
The results of the VOC analysis showed that there is a temperature dependent VOC profile of E. globulus biomass. The antennae of the fire beetle M. atrata can detect the key components in heated biomass in order to approach a woodland fire. The proposed sensor setup can detect these key components and allows an early fire warning in plantations or forests. Further research has to be conducted on the performance of the sensor system under field conditions.
5. Acknowledgements
The author is grateful to Brian Inglis from the Swan
Coastal District, Department of Environment and Conservation, Western Australia
and to Jan Seelig for their support during the field trips to Perth, Western
Australia and to Marta Paczkowska, Sarah Nicke, and David Lindgen for their
technical support. The author also wants to thank Prof. Dr. Stefan Schütz for supporting the trace analysis and the
electrophysiology by providing the laboratory space at the University of Göttingen, Germany. The author likes to thank the
botanical gardens of Stuttgart, Bochum, Bremen, Halle, Leipzig and Marburg for
providing the fresh E. globulus biomass.
Funding: This work was supported by the BMBF - Federal Ministry of Education
and Research, Germany [01RB0804A], and the Cusanuswerk, BischöflicheStudienstiftung, Germany. The funders had no
role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or
preparation of the manuscript.
Figure 1: Emission rates of the eucalypt wood, leaves, and wood and leaves in
ng/L×60s on a logarithmic scale for each temperature step between 25°C and 300°C.
For all VOC data sets, the median, the upper and lower quartile, the maximum
and the minimum are displayed in box plots. The dotted lines group the VOCs in
terpenes, furans, methoxyphenols and the benzene compound
Figure 2: Results of the electrophysiological studies on the antenna of M. atrata.
The antennal responses are given in mV and data sets (N=5) are displayed
showing the median, the upper and lower quartiles and the minimum and maximum
in box plots. Significant differences between the paraffin control and the
respective VOC dilution were calculated based on the Mann-Whitney U-test or the
t-test and displayed with stars (*: p<0.05; **: p<0.01; ***: p<0.001).
Figure 3: Dose response curves of M. atrata for eucalyptol, furfural and
2-methpoxyphenol. The relative response in % was calculated on the basis of an
individual standard stimulus.
Figure 4: Results of the sensor experiment. The three sensors can detect the two
stages of the thermal treatment of E. globulus biomass before ignition, which are the
terpene emission phase (25-150°C;
GGS5330 and GGS1330) and the onset of furan emission from degradation of
lignocellulose (150-200°C; GGS1330).
This sensor setup allows the detection of heated E. globulus biomass before it ignites and, therefore, can serve
as an early fire warning system to prevent the ignition of a fire or to allow a
fast response of fireman.
VOC |
Linear retention index (LRI) |
CAS No. of purchased standard VOCs |
Vapor pressure of pure VOC at SATP [mmHg] |
Terpenes |
|
|
|
α-Pinene |
937 |
80-56-8 |
4.75 |
Camphene |
952 |
79-92-5 |
3 |
β-Pinene |
980 |
127-91-3 |
2.93 |
β-Myrcene |
993 |
123-35-3 |
2.29 |
Limonene |
1037 |
138-86-3 |
1.55 |
Eucalyptol |
1042 |
470-82-6 |
1.9 |
Camphor |
1162 |
464-49-3 |
4 |
Aromadendrene |
1450 |
72747-25-2 |
0.02 |
Epiglobulol |
1583 |
88728-58-9 |
0.03 |
Furanes |
|
|
|
Furfural |
860 |
98-01-1 |
2.234 |
2-Furanmethanol |
877 |
98-00-0 |
1.009 |
5H-Furan-2-one |
950 |
497-23-4 |
0.273 |
5-Methylfurfural |
975 |
620-02-0 |
0.644 |
5-Hydroxymethylfurfural |
1245 |
67-47-0 |
0.001 |
Methoxyphenols |
|
|
|
2-Methoxyphenol |
1105 |
90-05-1 |
0.179 |
4-Methyl-2-methoxyphenol |
1209 |
93-51-6 |
0.078 |
4-Ethyl-2-methoxyphenol |
1296 |
2785-89-9 |
0.017 |
2-Methoxy-4-(2)-propenylphenol |
1375 |
97-53-0 |
0.01 |
2-Methoxy-4-formylphenol |
1421 |
121-33-5 |
0.002 |
Benzenes |
|
|
|
1-Isopropyl-4-methylbenzene |
1031 |
99-87-6 |
1.46 |
Table 1: The identified and quantified VOCs from the wood and leave, leave, and wood samples. The VOCs are assigned to their respective chemical group and, within this group, listed in the order of their linear retention index. The CAS number of the purchased standard VOC is given for exact identification and the vapor pressure of the VOCs for interpreting the results of the EAG are given, as well.
4.
Rexfort C (2006) Combination
of a fire model and a smoke detector sensor model. Fire Safety J 41: 252-257.
9.
Fengel D, Wegener G (1984) Wood: Chemistry,
Ultrastructure, Reactions. De Gruyter Inc Berlin.
19.
Kohl CD (2003) Electronic
Noses. In: Waser R editor, Nanoelectronics and information technology - Advanced
electronic materials and novel devices. Wiley-VCH. Berlin.
21.
Nicolay X (2006) Odors in the
food industry. Springer. New York.
23.
Pelosi P, Maida R (1995) Odorant-binding proteins in insects. Comp
Biochem Phy B 111: 503-514.
27.
Schmitz H, Bleckmann H, Murtz M (1997) Infrared detection in a beetle.
Nature 386: 773-774.
32.
Brabauskas V (2002) Ignition of wood: A review of the
state of the art. J Fire Prot Eng 12: 163-189.